ST Alpha - "there seem to be potential tax ramifications and maybe legal... -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

In response to "I found this -- (link)" by Beaker

there seem to be potential tax ramifications and maybe legal... -- nm

Posted by Beaker (aka Anniebecca) Mar 27 '11, 11:49

(No message)

Responses:

I think the tax ramifications relate to the seller. If the bank forgives a portion of the loan, that 'can' be considered income. - MojaveMeg Mar 27, 11:58 13
- So, if you buy a car and you get a 'rebate' for several thousand in the mail later, is that income? -- nm - zeitgeist Mar 27, 12:00 11
  - you want theory or actually what happens? - tRuMaN Mar 27, 12:03 1
    - how about a free flight for your airline miles? stay a few nights and get a free night? -- nm - zeitgeist Mar 27, 12:08
  - No, because that's a discount on the price of the car. The seller has reduced the price. But on a mortgage the bank is not the seller, they've only - MojaveMeg Mar 27, 12:03 5
    - its still a post sale negotiation wherein the value of the house re-appraised based on new information, conditions -- nm - zeitgeist Mar 27, 12:11
    - when you get a rebate on a car, you pay tax on the full amount, right? -- nm - amanda jones Mar 27, 12:06 3
      - Not sure - but if you do, that's sales tax not income tax. -- nm - MojaveMeg Mar 27, 12:09 2
        
        right, that's my point. it's different taxation. -- nm - amanda jones Mar 27, 12:11 1
        
        and you're *paying* the full price -- you're just getting some back. -- nm - amanda jones Mar 27, 12:13
  - I don't see why it would be considered income when they are just renegotiating the sale price which can happen in other contracts -- nm - zeitgeist Mar 27, 12:02 2
    - because it's reducing your existing obligation to pay the full amount of the mortgage -- nm - moles Mar 27, 12:13 1
      - I think I am actually ok with shortages being income. I don't think sellers should be able to walk away with no ... whatever. -- nm - amanda jones Mar 27, 12:14
- OTOH, my friends are buying an avocado orchard via a short sale :) -- nm - MojaveMeg Mar 27, 11:59

Post a message top

there seem to be potential tax ramifications and maybe legal... -- nm

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.