ST Alpha - "Sucker Punch - I don't know what to grade it." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

In response to "Weekend Movies -- Winter's Bone, A; Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, A+ -- nm" by znufrii

Sucker Punch - I don't know what to grade it.

Posted by Kim Pine (aka Callisto) Mar 28 '11, 07:03

I hated it but I also think there's so much missed potential that my mind has been spinning over all the things that could have been done better. Since it's made me think so much (and set creative juices flowing) I can't fault it completely.

Responses:

the first action sequence is stunning. - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:13 2
- spoils - Kim Pine Mar 28, 07:17 1
  - I had the same problem with that as well...(spoilers) - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:24
I don't know what grade to give it either. It really could have worked well, but missed badly. - Diva Mar 28, 07:11 19
- I feel like there was an excellent R-rated movie hidden in there somewhere. -- nm - Ender Mar 28, 07:15 5
  - the guy who played the club owner said they cut most of his lines as they were going for pg 13 -- nm - Remlik on the new 'droid Mar 28, 08:23
  - You people need to stop settling. NC-17/XXX or die! -- nm - David Mar 28, 07:22 1
    - Yes!! -- nm - Epiphany Mar 28, 07:38
  - qale said this -- why did the studio need pg-13? -- (link) - amanda jones, transitarian Mar 28, 07:20 [Backboard]
  - yep. agreed. -- nm - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:18
- I was thinking this morning...I really hope it doesn't derail Snyder's ability to get stuff made. - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:14 12
  - He's making the next Superman movie. -- nm - Diva Mar 28, 07:17 11
    - Supes is going to be a bad-ass then. - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:19 10
      - Did you see Owls of Ga'Hoole? - Kim Pine Mar 28, 07:24 9
        
        No. I couldn't think of a movie I had less interest in recently. -- nm - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:25 8
        
        Mars Needs Moms? -- nm - Beryllium (iPhone) Mar 28, 07:32 7
        
        I think I'd see that, if forced, first. Warrior Owls makes me laugh. -- nm - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:33 6
        
        that was Snyder, too. It suffers from the same sort of shiny but pointless that Sucker Punch kind of does. -- nm - Kim Pine Mar 28, 07:35 5
        
        that's unfortunate. -- nm - Mel Profit Mar 28, 07:40
        
        And has a similarly ill-considered villain. - David Mar 28, 07:39 3
        
        a film director in love with his toys at the expense of character and storytelling? say it isn't so! :) -- nm - znufrii Mar 28, 07:45
        
        spoiler question - Diva Mar 28, 07:43 1
        
        Spoilers - David Mar 28, 07:54

Post a message top

Sucker Punch - I don't know what to grade it.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.