ST Alpha - "Based on their performance on TDS I wouldn't search out their back catalog." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 151

In response to "Their first album is all kinds of awesome. nm" by Dignan

Based on their performance on TDS I wouldn't search out their back catalog.

Posted by TWuG Apr 11 '11, 20:36

Grohl was screaming not singing. And there was zero interesting in the arrangements.

Responses:

Based on this comment, I won't search for TWuG's earlier posts -- nm - Roger More Apr 11, 20:46 1
- Wisest decision you've ever made. Bar none. -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:05
no one ever really sounds good on late night shows -- nm - Gwaahjo Apr 11, 20:44 2
- except The Heavy. -- nm - Reagen Apr 11, 20:59
- For real -- nm - Epiphany Apr 11, 20:45
You just can't judge such a versatile band on one song. nm - Dignan Apr 11, 20:40 29
- Two. Both were from their new album, I think. - TWuG Apr 11, 20:45 28
  - I love the foo fighters in this very quiet way. I have all of their stuff, but never really listen to it, but when I hear a song on the radio, I am - amanda jones Apr 11, 21:00 1
    - I find when you think about them offhand you really just think of that first disc, but if you really think about it every disc of theirs has at least 2 songs you absolutely know by heart. -- nm - Ender Apr 11, 21:13
  - I can't imagine having never heard one of their songs. - Dignan Apr 11, 20:53 24
    - Yeah, jsut so I'm clear, TWuG, you've never heard this song? -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:56 [youtube] 21
      - Nope. -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:06
      - Didn't TWuG watch The West Wing? -- nm - nubby Apr 11, 20:57
      - or this one? -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:56 [youtube] 18
        
        Nope. But that is strikingly different in tone from what was played on TDS - TWuG Apr 11, 21:07 1
        
        This is their least typical song in their catalog, but was a gigantic hit. -- nm - Reagen Apr 11, 21:08
        
        or this one? -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:56 [youtube] 15
        
        Not that one either. -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:08
        
        or this -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:57 [youtube] 13
        
        Nor this one. -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:09
        
        or this? -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:57 [youtube] 11
        
        Not that one, either -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:10
        
        Oh yeah. This probably got more airplay than any of them. nm - Dignan Apr 11, 21:01 1
        
        Oh man, why did I click on it! WHYYYYY???? -- nm - Qale Apr 11, 21:30
        
        or (last one) this? -- (link) - Reagen Apr 11, 20:58 [youtube] 7
        
        I had also forgotten Tenacious D was in the video. -- nm - Tim Apr 11, 21:12 2
        
        what's the timeline, was this before or after Tribute? -- nm - Reagen Apr 11, 21:13 1
        
        Learn to Fly is 1999, Tenacious D's album was 2001. -- nm - Tim Apr 11, 21:17
        
        Hey! I know that one! It doesn't suck, but I don't really like it either. -- nm - TWuG Apr 11, 21:11 2
        
        You will have to take my word for this, but all these songs were massive, massive hits. -- nm - Reagen Apr 11, 21:12 1
        
        Word taken. - TWuG Apr 11, 21:17
        
        Or did he ever watch Ed? -- nm - Tim Apr 11, 20:59
    - (and Big Me was played *everywhere* when it came out.) nm - Dignan Apr 11, 20:54 1
      - Footos! -- nm - Tim Apr 11, 20:54
  - I'm just trying to figure out what cave you live in that you've never heard the Foos. - Reagen Apr 11, 20:49

Post a message top

Based on their performance on TDS I wouldn't search out their back catalog.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.