|
In response to
"Weekend Movie Poll: Revolver - C, Devil - B, Tangled - A"
by
Hotkiss
|
Potter 7.1 = B; Black Swan = C+; Narnia 3 = D
Posted by
Will Hunting (aka JoeMetz)
Apr 25 '11, 07:50
|
Potter could change depending on how they handle Part 2, it could either be a perfect bridge or it could be lacking; notably the entirety of Dumbledore's history that's heavy in Book 7; to have Harry question who/why he's following the words of a guy he didn't know. But I can't recall when in the book that's heavily dealt with.
Black Swan; I hate movies that try to be mind-fucky and lose the cohesion. So, you're supposed to wonder what's real, what's not...but frankly, she didn't exist in a vacuum so unless the entire movie was not real, it didn't work for me; but Portman was good so it gets a slightly above average grade.
Narnia 3 -- I watched it and I don't know why I finished it. I can't tell you a single part of the movie I remember other than bad things like the single worst child-actor I've ever seen on film.
|