ST Alpha - "probably a bit of both -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

probably a bit of both -- nm

Posted by tRuMaN (aka Truman) May 9 '11, 06:21

(No message)

Responses:

[deleted] 21
- That was where my suspension of disbelief was tested too. That and the (spoils) - bc/nc May 9, 06:26 12
  - *rides in on a hypogriff being chased by dementors, waving a magic wand and yelling 'Accio!'* -- nm - JaxSean May 9, 06:45
  - I'd have felt better about the (spoils) - Jim May 9, 06:37 9
    - I don't get why that's a sticking point. *spoils* - Ender May 9, 06:41 1
      - Like I said...I'm not hugely concerned about it. I just think it would have added a little something (spoils) - Jim May 9, 06:45
    - well, spoils - tRuMaN May 9, 06:38 6
      - Oh yeah...what bothered me (a little bit...not like majorly - spoils) - Jim May 9, 06:41 3
        
        actually this makes sense for me. sp - amanda jones May 9, 06:53
        
        I think there is a rationale for it in context of the entire trilogy, but since you're only on book one, I won't delve into it. -- nm - TFox May 9, 06:45 1
        
        very cool. Again, it's a minor bitch. I have GOT to get the other books. -- nm - Jim May 9, 06:45
      - *try to* -- we don't see anyone else succeeding. -- nm - amanda jones May 9, 06:39 1
        
        though (spoils) - TFox May 9, 06:42
  - agreed. -- nm - tRuMaN May 9, 06:34
- (spoils) - Jim May 9, 06:26 5
  - I thought the creation of the worlds was thin, the characters were thin, etc. It felt like a bare bones first draft that could have been filled out. -- nm - Dano May 9, 06:51
  - I'm with you. (spoils) - JaxSean May 9, 06:28 3
    - That I wasn't so sure of. I kept waiting for (spoils) - Jim May 9, 06:30 2
      - [deleted] 1
        
        I'm right with you on that. And I haven't read Catching Fire yet either. -- nm - Jim May 9, 06:38
- Like Jim says below in Dano's thread... - JaxSean May 9, 06:24 1
  - Whoa...I said it up here too. :) -- nm - Jim May 9, 06:27

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.