ST Alpha - "You are correct. " (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

In response to "Samara becuase her 3 skill keepers were Chris Johnson, Andre Johnson and Jamaal Charles iirc. -- nm" by Will Hunting

You are correct.

Posted by Name Withheld By Request (aka BlueKopo) Aug 25 '11, 11:18

I think we were a stingy bunch on trade offers this season. Nobody really offered a house for anyone else.

Responses:

I think Kelly overpaid for Vick. -- nm - Strongbad Aug 25, 11:25 18
- If it's 2010 Michael Vick, getting 27ppg...no, she didn't. - Will Hunting Aug 25, 11:31 6
  - you could also say that he's got a lot to prove still so may be way more motivated to do super well? - JenBro Aug 25, 11:36 3
    - I don't play shrink...i just know that in 2010, he was dominant to a level that few players ever have been. -- nm - Will Hunting Aug 25, 11:37 2
      - And the only thing that makes that trade even partly okay is I got him off the waiver wire. - Bacon @Home Aug 25, 11:38 1
        
        You got the 4th pick in a draft when you had a fallback who's a numberical top 5 guy....there's zero way you should feel bad - Will Hunting Aug 25, 11:40
  - Maybe I'm just not as high on Vick as most people. -- nm - Strongbad Aug 25, 11:35
  - He is awesome because he gets 1 point per 10 yards rushed. Then you get all the rushing TD's on top of the passing. - Bacon @Home Aug 25, 11:34
- I offered my late Round Two, but only because I thought our league would be cheap. I think he's Round One value for a team w/o an elite QB. -- nm - Name Withheld By Request Aug 25, 11:28 2
  - I would have dropped Rivers first -- nm - Bacon @Home Aug 25, 11:32 1
    - Then the same offer would have been extended for him. (I have Rivers as the safer choice this year anyhow.) -- nm - Name Withheld By Request Aug 25, 11:33
- I don't think she overpaid for Vick, but I don't think she' got proper value for Matt Ryan. -- nm - samara Aug 25, 11:27 4
  - What would you consider proper value? -- nm - Will Hunting Aug 25, 11:33 3
    - iirc, she only moved up two rounds in exchange for him. didn't seem like enough. -- nm - samara Aug 25, 11:35 2
      - It was swapping 5th for a 7th. - Strongbad Aug 25, 11:37
      - I don't think there was a better deal to be had for Ryan. He's a fringy Top Ten option. - Name Withheld By Request Aug 25, 11:36
- I would trade her back in a second. That was a hard pill I had to swallow. - Bacon @Home Aug 25, 11:26 2
  - No way. - Strongbad Aug 25, 11:28 1
    - Well I needed to find a person that needed a QB. Vick for a 1st round pick, IN A KEEPER League? where the talent is already taken mostly? - Bacon @Home Aug 25, 11:29
well, except my dumb ass. -- nm - TFox Aug 25, 11:19 4
- You were first out of the gate. That's almost always an overpay. (Think me and Forte last year.) -- nm - Name Withheld By Request Aug 25, 11:22 3
  - Did I trade you Forte? I can't remember... -- nm - samara Aug 25, 11:23 1
    - Yes. And then I got cute, thought I could claim him back in the 2nd of all rounds, so I dropped him in favour of.... - Name Withheld By Request Aug 25, 11:27
  - I knew I'd gone overboard as soon as Redmond wrote me back so fast... but I was sort of stuck then. -- nm - TFox Aug 25, 11:22

Post a message top

You are correct.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.