ST Alpha - "Disagreed." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

In response to "my problem with fantasy hockey is not about the stats and/or the ability to track them." by Reagen

Disagreed.

Posted by The Ruiner (aka Spawn) Sep 26 '11, 12:09

Basketball works fine.
Baseball works fine.

Responses:

basketball does not work fine at all. fantasy basketball is barely functional. -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:14 28
- And at least that has a core of 5 key stats to track before you get to the percentage stats -- nm - Will Hunting Sep 26, 12:15 20
  - i also hate, *hate*, that fantasy basketball has stats that reward inactivity. - TFox Sep 26, 12:17 19
    - I agree with this but I love fantasy basketball. - Krusty Sep 26, 12:24 16
      - I disagree with the turnovers. Who cares if a manager wins that *one* stat by being inactive? He gets buried in the others. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:31 1
        
        I don't hate using them but I prefer to not use negative categories. -- nm - Krusty Sep 26, 12:38
      - i've yet to see a correctly set up league in that regard, but if you ever have one, let me know! -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:25 13
        
        If we ever have basketball I'll be sure and do that. Stupid lockout. - Krusty Sep 26, 12:30 12
        
        college would be better, truthfully. the games are played on a far more predictable schedule. -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:33 11
        
        Why do you need predictable? Your roster page tells you what you need. -- nm - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:36 8
        
        any of the games that mandate daily roster checks for success are totally obnoxious. - TFox Sep 26, 12:43 7
        
        I disagree. Baseball requires more checking than basketball due to pitching. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:51 2
        
        it really doesn't. -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:51 1
        
        So, how do you know when someone is going to pitch? And even if you do, they make changes, anyway. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:53
        
        This is why I hate instant FA pickups in football. -- nm - Strongbad Sep 26, 12:47 3
        
        Strongly disagree. I have 1 football league with waivers that I am probably not playing next year. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:52
        
        agreed*. - TFox Sep 26, 12:50 1
        
        The best way to go is a bidding system with transactions processed on Friday, but this is too complicated to implement for BF. -- nm - Strongbad Sep 26, 12:54
        
        I don't think there's any college fantasy games other than pick 'em. - Krusty Sep 26, 12:36 1
        
        ESPN does some College Football salary cap-style contests. -- nm - Strongbad Sep 26, 12:37
    - Doesn't baseball do this too? I've been in some H2H leagues with Errors, Losses, etc. -- nm - Strongbad Sep 26, 12:23 1
      - well yes, if you're in shitty mismanaged leagues that think they're smart. - TFox Sep 26, 12:24
- And the only way roto baseball is functional is with Innings limits or Total Starts caps. - Strongbad Sep 26, 12:15 1
  - inning limits in roto are pretty much standard now and very easy to manage to. -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:20
- Wow. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:15 4
  - the amount of work needed to successfully manage fantasy basketball makes fantasy baseball seem like fantasy football. -- nm - TFox Sep 26, 12:16 3
    - Hmmm. It does require a couple daily minutes but I have won a few leagues. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:18 2
      - I have won a baskeball league, and I do not even like the sport. nm -- nm - groiny Sep 26, 12:25 1
        
        About like me in baseball. -- nm - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:35
baseball, I get, since teams play basically everyday. - Reagen Sep 26, 12:10 5
- That's why I prefer roto for hockey and baseball -- nm - spamlet (iPhone) Sep 26, 12:38 1
  - Basketball, too. -- nm - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:40
- Ah. Not being a hockey watcher, I did not know that. - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:13 2
  - I'm joining CWG...and taking free and my area guys with me -- nm - Beaker Sep 26, 12:13 1
    - heh -- nm - The Ruiner Sep 26, 12:37

Post a message top

Disagreed.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.