ST Alpha - "Joey, I think the top three right now would be Clayton, McCutchen and Upton." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 158

Joey, I think the top three right now would be Clayton, McCutchen and Upton.

Posted by David (aka David) Dec 1 '11, 11:08

Although Strasburg may go ahead of even Clayton depending on who did that draft.

Responses:

You think McCutchen? Upton I could see...as I think he's the closest to the great CFers of the past - Will Hunting Dec 1, 11:09 1
- McCutchen is a freak defender with tremendous power and speed and CFs seem valued more than anything but SSs these days. -- nm - David Dec 1, 11:23
I am shocked Hellickson was so law, as the 2 Braves guys and no Terehan (sp) nm -- nm - groiny Dec 1, 11:08 17
- Teheran doesn't count since he's still eligible for ROY. Which 2 Braves? We had 6. - David Dec 1, 11:13 14
  - Trout still has eligibility? - groiny Dec 1, 11:15 13
    - I think it's 130 at bats and he wound up like 5 short of that. -- nm - David Dec 1, 11:18 11
      - Hmm, he had 135 plate appearances but 123 at bats. I'm going to have look at the rules for that. -- nm - David Dec 1, 11:19 10
        
        There was some issue where he was on the active roster for too long becuase they didn't option him down long enough in the middle part of the season. - Will Hunting Dec 1, 11:21
        
        I always thought it was 150? -- nm - Don Homer Dec 1, 11:19 8
        
        "The current standard of 130 at bats, 50 innings pitched or 45 days on the active roster of a Major League club (excluding time in military service or - David Dec 1, 11:21 7
        
        Nope, it's the 45 days on the roster part. He was called up July 8th - and never really went back down. - Will Hunting Dec 1, 11:23 5
        
        There is an Anaheim article on November 15 that says MLB hasn't ruled either way on that yet. - David Dec 1, 11:24 4
        
        Well, by the letter of the law, he's out....MLB can waive it, but that's the dealio. - Will Hunting Dec 1, 11:25 3
        
        That's the very article I referenced that I looked up 20 minutes ago. - David Dec 1, 11:27 2
        
        A sword fight with both parties using the same sword. - Spawn Dec 1, 11:32 1
        
        Go play Arkham City, Judas. -- nm - David Dec 1, 11:34
        
        oh, thanks. -- nm - Don Homer Dec 1, 11:23
    - No. Trout's done for ROY. (This was why he qualified for Law's list.) -- nm - Name Withheld By Request Dec 1, 11:17
- I don't think Terehan has the depth of MLB results yet to count for him. - Will Hunting Dec 1, 11:13 1
  - he specifically names Wieters in there that he is turning 26 . nm -- nm - groiny Dec 1, 11:15

Post a message top

Joey, I think the top three right now would be Clayton, McCutchen and Upton.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.