ST Alpha - "this is an excellent point. the best picture oscar is diluted somehow by the additional category. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 165

In response to "which means voters should have learned by now that great animated films have a sticking power that, often, "traditional" films don't." by TFox

this is an excellent point. the best picture oscar is diluted somehow by the additional category. -- nm

Posted by president 44 loves mandy lane (aka amanda) Jan 20 '09, 10:35

(No message)

Responses:

Thing is, Oscar has next to no history of nominating animation, with or without the animation category. - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:39 10
- [deleted] 4
  - the classics maybe (Snow White, Cinderella, Bambi, etc.....) but I don't know what they were up against. - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:51 2
    - [deleted] 1
      - But this conspiracy theory loses steam when you look at the various Foreign Film nominees that get nominated for the big prize - Will Hunting Jan 20, 11:02
  - the classics maybe (Snow White, Cinderella, Bambi, etc.....) but I don't know what they were up against. - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:50
- Not that it "would" have, that it "should" have. That in retrospect, you'd place an animated film in that year's top 5 repeatedly and often. - TFox Jan 20, 10:43 4
  - I would, but saying Oscar's lost it's mojo nominating animation isn't backed up by anything. - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:47 3
    - You aren't following my point. I'm not saying they've lost anything, I'm saying they should have figured out they've missed the boat on this by now. - TFox Jan 20, 10:51 2
      - Maybe so, but maybe because Disney flicks are timeless to children and we all saw these things regardless of legit quality - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:54 1
        
        I think this is true of many, but some are on another plane. -- nm - TFox Jan 20, 10:57
fully agree. The documentary and foreign film categories can dilute as well. -- nm - ty97 Jan 20, 10:37 3
- out of interest, has a documentary ever been nominated for BP? -- nm - Roger More Jan 20, 10:40 2
  - Nope -- nm - Mr. Havens Jan 20, 10:48
  - Hoops Dreams got shafted in just about every manner in 94. - Will Hunting Jan 20, 10:42

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.