ST Alpha - "I agree he had one stolen, but two wrongs don't make a right...his joker was ok, but not as good as studio PR said it was" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 169

In response to "now if Ledger doesn't get the Oscar I'm going on Jihad. " by Mel Profit

I agree he had one stolen, but two wrongs don't make a right...his joker was ok, but not as good as studio PR said it was

Posted by The Calico Cat Coalition (aka seandunham) Jan 22 '09, 07:57

Great for a popcorn film...and certainly much better than Bale's Batman...but still, I expected more.

Responses:

I'd disagree (and I thought overall TDK had a LOT of weaknesses). -- nm - Cuzzin Todd Jan 22, 08:14
Was Heath Ledger a Republican? -- nm - TFox Jan 22, 08:00
oh, my. I think he's a lock, and a deserving one at that. - Callisto Jan 22, 07:59 8
- I'm sorry, 100% disagree...he was good, but not any better than most other comicbook film villans - The Calico Cat Coalition Jan 22, 08:06 6
  - Are you sure you did not watch JNICH by mistake? - Rorschach: 03/06/09!!! Jan 22, 08:11
  - couldn't disagree more. - znufrii Jan 22, 08:09 1
    - Watch the movie again, and every scene that you remember him being an awesome Joker in...watch his tongue - The Calico Cat Coalition Jan 22, 08:14
  - So his performance was no better than Kevin Spacey's or Jeff Daniels'? -- nm - Shaun Jan 22, 08:08 1
    - Maybe a little, but certainly not Oscar quality...certainly not on par with the other nominees - The Calico Cat Coalition Jan 22, 08:11
  - nah, there's more than that. But I think I'm supposed to be in a meeting so I'll have to discuss later. -- nm - Callisto Jan 22, 08:06
- word - Rorschach: 03/06/09!!! Jan 22, 08:00
It's the definitive Joker now. - Mel Profit Jan 22, 07:59 7
- Related. I caught some of the 89 Batman on tv last night. It's almost been ruined by TDK. -- nm - Shaun Jan 22, 08:00 4
  - I think Jack's performance was destroyed. - Mel Profit Jan 22, 08:02 1
    - It was. I was almost cringing at it. -- nm - Shaun Jan 22, 08:03
  - I view it as an Elseworlds tale. - Rorschach: 03/06/09!!! Jan 22, 08:01 1
    - That's an interesting and fair take, I think. -- nm - emoticripple Jan 22, 08:02
- "Wanna see a magic trick?" (spoils) - TFox Jan 22, 08:00 1
  - word. I admit it, when I saw it the second time I pulled out my phone and videoed that one scene. -- nm - Rorschach: 03/06/09!!! Jan 22, 08:04

Post a message top

I agree he had one stolen, but two wrongs don't make a right...his joker was ok, but not as good as studio PR said it was

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.