ST Alpha - "1) Up 2) Monsters, Inc. 3) The Incredibles 4) Toy Story 3 5) Ratatouille 6) Finding Nemo 7) Wall-E 8) Toy Story 9) Toy Story 2 10) Cars 11) Cars 2 " (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

In response to "Heh. I figured this would be largely agreed with by ST... -- (link)" by Dr.Vermin

1) Up 2) Monsters, Inc. 3) The Incredibles 4) Toy Story 3 5) Ratatouille 6) Finding Nemo 7) Wall-E 8) Toy Story 9) Toy Story 2 10) Cars 11) Cars 2

Posted by kelly Jun 22 '12, 11:50

12) A Bug's Life

The last 2 are probably the only ones I don't love/really like

Responses:

I haven't seen either of the Cars - with how they're ranked on most of the lists here. no hurry, eh? -- nm - b. Jun 22, 11:52 17
- The first is up there in my group of "top Pixar". The second is at the bottom of my list -- nm - oblique Jun 22, 11:55 5
  - This. The first was very good. The second was awful. I wanted my money back. -- nm - Krusty Jun 22, 12:02 4
    - To me the first was an animated version of Doc Hollywood, but Doc Hollywood was better. - pmb Jun 22, 12:03 3
      - (except for all that racing stuff) - Spawn Jun 22, 12:11 2
        
        To me it was a superfluous part of the movie. You just substitute the racing for "doctoring" in Doc Hollywood. The heart of the story was the same. -- nm - pmb Jun 22, 12:13 1
        
        Yeah. Totally not the same. - Spawn Jun 22, 12:39
- I'd watch Cars. I think if you're a racing fan you'll like it more than if you are not. - spamlet Jun 22, 11:55 5
  - Not a racing fan. That (and Larry the Cable Guy) were why I avoided the movie for so long. - Spawn Jun 22, 12:07 2
    - Now I have this image of Logan putting you in a headlock and making you type that IM -- nm - oblique Jun 22, 12:08 1
      - Nope. I have seen it far more than any other Pixar and I would have no problem watching it again. -- nm - Spawn Jun 22, 12:09
  - yeah, that's a pretty good summary of 2. -- nm - Don Homer Jun 22, 11:55 1
    - It's almost like they were working on a Bond spoof when Disney bought them out and told them to make Cars 2. -- nm - spamlet Jun 22, 11:57
- I like Cars 1 a lot. It's hard to rank these, because so many of them are *soclose* in greatness. - kelly Jun 22, 11:54 3
  - That's why mine is in tiers. For me, the items in each tier could rearrange, but the tiers are fairly consistent. -- nm - spamlet Jun 22, 11:56 1
    - Yeah, that's about right. -- nm - kelly Jun 22, 11:58
  - thanks, guys - maybe I'll watch the first before too long. -- nm - b. Jun 22, 11:55
- The first one is solid, the second has a couple decent moments and impressive animation but is otherwise skippable. -- nm - Don Homer Jun 22, 11:53

Post a message top

1) Up 2) Monsters, Inc. 3) The Incredibles 4) Toy Story 3 5) Ratatouille 6) Finding Nemo 7) Wall-E 8) Toy Story 9) Toy Story 2 10) Cars 11) Cars 2

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.