ST Alpha - "So Mariah Carey, Nick Jonas, and Pharrell Williams are reportedly our new American Idol judges?" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 159

So Mariah Carey, Nick Jonas, and Pharrell Williams are reportedly our new American Idol judges?

Posted by Mop (197 lbs) (aka rburriel) Aug 2 '12, 15:50

I didn't know Randy had stepped down. Honestly, I think this is a good set. Nice variety, with plenty of knowledge and experience. I don't know if any of them are going to be as... blunt... as Simon ever was, but one can hope.

Mop

Responses:

That doesn't sound like a random selection of music personalities at all! -- nm - Reagen Aug 2, 15:54
If you replace all of the original judges, why is it relevant as American Idol? Seacrest? -- nm - Qale Aug 2, 15:51 4
- Sure, Seacrest, the format, the producers (Simon Fuller's still the boss). -- nm - Mop (197 lbs) Aug 2, 15:52 3
  - See, I disagree. It becomes just another singing competition show. -- nm - Qale Aug 2, 16:00 2
    - AI lost any uniqueness when they decided to copy the X-Factor "big number production" format. -- nm - Mop (197 lbs) Aug 2, 16:16 1
      - This is why I like America's Got Talent. So many more ways to be good and bad. - the liioulu with Aug 2, 17:16

Post a message top

So Mariah Carey, Nick Jonas, and Pharrell Williams are reportedly our new American Idol judges?

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.