ST Alpha - "Finally we'll have an answer: Did Jack Dawson have to die? -- (link)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

Finally we'll have an answer: Did Jack Dawson have to die? -- (link)

Posted by Ender (aka Ender) Oct 4 '12, 12:19

(No message)

'MythBusters' to settle 'Titanic' debate this Sunday: Did Jack have to die? (insidetv.ew.com)

Responses:

they would have died below decks with all that slosshing around in the water there, that's freaking cold water, you're toes would spasm stepping in it -- nm - zeitgeist Oct 4, 12:40
I'll say yes, even though I've never seen the movie. -- nm - CovingtonCat Oct 4, 12:28
did anyone see the 1944 Nazi version of Titanic on TCM last sunday? They had 50% of Camerons plot including - peglegpete Oct 4, 12:28
Yes. If not, then there's no story. -- nm - JaxSean Oct 4, 12:25 12
- She could have died - eag Oct 4, 12:27 10
  - fact - she almost certainly would have beenpulled down by the weight of her dress when wet. -- nm - Andie Oct 4, 12:30 4
    - and I'm pretty sure she would have succummbed to hypothermia, regardless. -- nm - znufrii Oct 4, 12:30 3
      - They're testing the hypothermia angle too. -- nm - Ender Oct 4, 12:37 1
        
        yeah, saw that. - znufrii Oct 4, 12:38
      - i think in reality they pulled 5 *men* from the water alive and then 2 of them died. I should confirm that on wiki. - Andie Oct 4, 12:35
  - except - loosilu Oct 4, 12:27 4
    - She could have given it to him before she perrished - eag Oct 4, 12:29 3
      - she didn't even know she had. -- nm - Andie Oct 4, 12:35 2
        
        .. it. -- nm - Andie Oct 4, 12:35 1
        
        Not you too - eag Oct 4, 12:37
- yup. - znufrii Oct 4, 12:26
SPOILER!~!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -- nm - peglegpete Oct 4, 12:24
I keep saying that Rose let him die - eag Oct 4, 12:24 1
- heh -- nm - JaxSean Oct 4, 12:41
*fingers crossed for yes* -- nm - ST Conservatives Oct 4, 12:23

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.