ST Alpha - "Of the Oscar Best Picture nominees I've seen I think I would rank them this way: 1) Frost/Nixon, 2) Benjamin Button, 3) Slumdog Millionaire. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

Of the Oscar Best Picture nominees I've seen I think I would rank them this way: 1) Frost/Nixon, 2) Benjamin Button, 3) Slumdog Millionaire. -- nm

Posted by Don Homer (aka DonHomer) Feb 17 '09, 05:59

(No message)

Responses:

1) Slumdog, 2) The Reader, 3) Benjamin Button, 4) Milk, 5) Frost/Nixon. -- nm - Jelly Feb 17, 06:07
1) Slumdog 2) Frost/Nixon 3) Milk (big gap) 4) Button (bigger gap) 5) The Reader -- nm - David Feb 17, 06:07 2
- sfan - Callisto Feb 17, 06:08 1
  - laughing. I knew I'd seen David say Frost/Nixon was the only one in his Top 10. - ty97 Feb 17, 06:09
1) Slumdog 2) Milk. [large gap between 2 and 3] 3) Button. -- nm - ty97 Feb 17, 06:06
1. Benjamin Button; 2. Slumdog; 3. Frost/Nixon; 4. Milk; 5. The Reader -- nm - secretslacker Feb 17, 06:05 12
- I put Man on Wire above ALL of these and WALL*E between 1 and 2 -- nm - secretslacker Feb 17, 06:06 11
  - I am genuinely baffled by the Man on Wire lovefest - Will Hunting Feb 17, 06:09 10
    - Small addendum: Wall-E needed a strong B-plot for me to put it in this discussion - Will Hunting Feb 17, 06:17
    - Yeah, but you're not a New Yorker. :) -- nm - secretslacker Feb 17, 06:11 4
      - I don't even know how to respond to this. - Will Hunting Feb 17, 06:13 3
        
        There are so many levels to this film... - secretslacker Feb 17, 06:16 2
        
        In speaking to the latter...I think that was the biggest failing of the movie. - Will Hunting Feb 17, 06:19
        
        and the realization of the simple fact that... - znufrii Feb 17, 06:18
    - Yeah, I don't even know if its one of the top 10 documentaries I've ever seen. -- nm - TFox Feb 17, 06:09 3
      - It's definitely nowhere near my top 10. nm - Dignan Feb 17, 06:12
      - have you even *seen* 10 documentaries? - znufrii Feb 17, 06:11 1
        
        Oh heck yeah. - TFox Feb 17, 06:13
1) Slumdog, 2) Frost/Nixon, 99) Button -- nm - LMS Feb 17, 06:05
1) Slumdog/ Milk 2) Button -- nm - MDH Feb 17, 06:01
1) Benjamin Button, 2) Slumdog Millionaire, 3) Milk -- nm - znufrii Feb 17, 06:01 1
- and 1a) WALL-E, 2a) Man On Wire -- nm - znufrii Feb 17, 06:01
I'd rank them: 1) Wall*E. 2) The rest. -- nm - Jim Feb 17, 06:00 2
- I consider Wall-E nom-worthy, but wouldn't rank it #1 of the noms. -- nm - ty97 Feb 17, 06:08
- *uber-ding* -- nm - TFox Feb 17, 06:03

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.