ST Alpha - "ST Poll: What current MLB player, who has been in the league less than 10 seaons, can you say definitively, makes the hall? nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

ST Poll: What current MLB player, who has been in the league less than 10 seaons, can you say definitively, makes the hall? nm

Posted by Jovian (aka Jovian) Feb 17 '09, 18:05

.

Responses:

Halladay! -- nm - J Feb 17, 18:34 6
- I just looked him up b/c I was curious. He's awesome, but statwise I think he still needs a solid number of seasons more. -- nm - TFox Feb 17, 18:35 5
  - I checked too and this will be his 11th season. Too many years to qualify buy he's close. He's got more complete games than I've ever seen from - Krusty - Springfield Hall of Famer Feb 17, 18:41 4
    - wow, I wouldn't have known the 11 year mark -- nm - J Feb 17, 18:42 1
      - His first four seasons were unremarkable and iirc he got some help with his pitching motion and became an entirely different pitcher. -- nm - Krusty - Springfield Hall of Famer Feb 17, 18:44
    - Few of those are injury shortened too. If he can pitch at a high level to 36 or 37, I think he has a very solid case. -- nm - TFox Feb 17, 18:42 1
      - I'm betting he takes a big contract in 2011 that gets him the attention needed over three years or so that push him over the top. -- nm - Name Withheld By Request Feb 17, 22:47
Pujols*. Ichiro. Johan Santana. - Will Hunting Feb 17, 18:06 7
- Berkman has some very nice stats, he could be on his way too. -- nm - Krusty - Springfield Hall of Famer Feb 17, 18:29
- [deleted]
- These three, and then I need to start taking some leaps for young guys. - TFox Feb 17, 18:11 4
  - HAnley Ramirez maybe -- nm - CQ Feb 17, 18:21
  - Possibly Utley, based on position. -- nm - Krusty - Springfield Hall of Famer Feb 17, 18:20 2
    - Hell, Hanley could do it too. Plenty of people have the talent, but nowhere near the longevity. -- nm - TFox Feb 17, 18:21 1
      - Wright also has great numbers but has also been in the league for 5 years. At this point in his career, Mattingly was looking like a HOFer too. One - Krusty - Springfield Hall of Famer Feb 17, 18:24

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.