ST Alpha - "I don't think Benoit ever gets in (and shouldn't) but I am glad they are opening up his old matches for viewing though" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 161

In response to "Continuing from b2 or b3 irregardless of what Randy Savage may or may have not done he deserves to bein the HOF " by eag

I don't think Benoit ever gets in (and shouldn't) but I am glad they are opening up his old matches for viewing though

Posted by Beaker (aka anniebecca) Jan 14 '14, 09:51

this from a huge Benoit fan before everything went to plaid

Responses:

I was just thinking how they were gonna do that on the network - eag Jan 14, 09:53 2
- They've said in press for the Network that they will not excise his history in the WWE.... - Remlik Jan 14, 09:55
- I see no reason to try to wipe him from existance. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 09:53
no, he never truly ever hit superstar level IMO. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 09:52 45
- He was a WCW *and* WWF champion and the best wrestler in the world. He was a slam dunk. - David Jan 14, 10:07 26
  - in those years, championships changed hands every month. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 10:08 25
    - He would have been the WCW champion for a long time if he had stayed. It was a CM Punk situation. -- nm - David Jan 14, 10:18 22
      - I put Beniot and Luger is a very similar status. - groiny Jan 14, 10:22 3
        
        I am with you on Luger. Zero mic skills. -- nm - Shaun Jan 14, 10:31
        
        Benoit had that one thing that no guy has now and likely never will again... - Mel Profit Jan 14, 10:26 1
        
        right, his ring abilities were top notch. I certainly do not dispute that. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 10:28
      - I am not so sure. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 10:20 16
        
        There's no denying it. They made him champion to try to get him to stay. - David Jan 14, 10:23 15
        
        Perry Saturn was the 4th -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:26 4
        
        didn't the WWE do a huge Jericho puch shortly before that? - groiny Jan 14, 10:27 3
        
        Actually --- Jericho debuted in July/August 99....the Benoit 4 jumped in Jan/Feb 2000... - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:34 1
        
        well, Jericho was a better ring presence than Benoit, so there is that. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 10:35
        
        yeah at least a year before that. -- nm - Remlik Jan 14, 10:30
        
        and why did he walk out then? - groiny Jan 14, 10:24 9
        
        Do you not remember this at all? He felt Bischoff had mistreated him for years. -- nm - David Jan 14, 10:26 8
        
        so, he was underused for years in the WCW..... - groiny Jan 14, 10:27 4
        
        How many guys are immediately given a heel faction and a title run when they join a new company? - David Jan 14, 10:30 3
        
        and keep in mind, I was a big fan of Benoit. - groiny Jan 14, 10:34
        
        where are all the Benoit T-Shirts? - groiny Jan 14, 10:33 1
        
        WCW was near death when he left. They were about 13months from being bought out. -- nm - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:35
        
        (And Chris Sullivan, the ex of his girlfriend, was the WCW booker at the time) -- nm - David Jan 14, 10:27 2
        
        and they haaaaaaaated each other -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:28 1
        
        (the guy who writes wrestling stuff for Grantland posted some from his book on this subject recently) -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:29
      - David Arquette was the WCW champion at one point. I think that pretty well negates that as a HOF qualifier, yes? -- nm - Jim Jan 14, 10:20
    - don't blame the wrestlers for WCW's stupidity -- nm - i'm not dead yet ! Jan 14, 10:16 1
      - you have to, if you are using championships as a guage. - groiny Jan 14, 10:19
- i have to diagree here ... he busted his ass for years before getting the recognition and title stuff that he deserved ... - i'm not dead yet ! Jan 14, 09:54 7
  - You're over-stating his career / impact. - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:01 4
    - Randy Orton's personality isnt really much better than Benoit's - eag Jan 14, 10:03 3
      - Orton's personality sucks, but he's tall, built and reasonably handsome.... - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:04 2
        
        Plus, the RKO rules. -- nm - Shaun Jan 14, 10:12
        
        *poops in your luggage* -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:05
  - there are a ton of wrestlers who were great in the ring, but to be superstar level, they have to do more than that. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 09:56
  - he was definately a gatekeeper....he was the guy if you could have a great match with you got pushed to the A level.. - Remlik Jan 14, 09:56
- I think had he not gone postal on his family he would have gotten in -- nm - eag Jan 14, 09:53 9
  - Koko B Ware is in the WWE Hall of Fame. Let's not treat it as anything approaching legitimate. -- nm - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:02 5
    - And sadly The Bushwackers are not in -- nm - eag Jan 14, 10:06 1
      - if Luke and Butch get in I hope it is as The Sheepherders -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:08
    - did the parrot get in to? -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:03 2
      - Frankie went in before Koko. -- nm - Will Hunting Jan 14, 10:03 1
        
        heh awesome -- nm - Beaker Jan 14, 10:05
  - his ring skills were fantastic, his mic skills were not. nm -- nm - groiny Jan 14, 09:54 2
    - agree. -- nm - Remlik Jan 14, 09:56
    - Agree -- nm - eag Jan 14, 09:55

Post a message top

I don't think Benoit ever gets in (and shouldn't) but I am glad they are opening up his old matches for viewing though

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.