ST Alpha - "Just because Bin Laden "united" America, it doesn't justify the means. He still needs to answer for the crime. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

In response to "But the means have already happened, so why not enjoy the end? -- nm" by Cuzzin Todd

Just because Bin Laden "united" America, it doesn't justify the means. He still needs to answer for the crime. -- nm

Posted by JaxSean (aka JaxSean) Mar 3 '09, 10:15

(No message)

Responses:

How did UBL get brought into this seeing as in the original post; - Loyola Mar 3, 10:20 10
- Because while it wasn't the original intent of the action, it still brought a nation together to focus and champion a cause against Terrorism. - JaxSean Mar 3, 10:24 4
  - But for the analogy to hold, that line of thought would have you believe that the nation pre 9/11 was tearing itself apart. - Loyola Mar 3, 10:27 2
    - well, take a look at the 2000 election... -- nm - znufrii, older, no wiser Mar 3, 10:29 1
      - Hardly at the brink of nuclear war now. In fairness like. -- nm - Loyola Mar 3, 10:32
  - Now, let's expand on that: Bush and Chaney faked the 911 attacks but succeeded in eliminating terrorism. You know they - TWuG Mar 3, 10:27
- Basically, after 9/11, it was the world vs Afghanistan/Al Queda. - Will Hunting Mar 3, 10:21 4
  - But that international unity fell apart pretty quickly as different countries had different ideas on how to respond to the threat -- nm - Alan More Mar 3, 10:23 2
    - And, of course, after Bush opened his mouth ... -- nm - Beryllium Mar 3, 10:24 1
      - that was *one* of the different ideas. I don't put it all on Bush though -- nm - Alan More Mar 3, 10:25
  - for a coulpe weeks, at least -- nm - znufrii, older, no wiser Mar 3, 10:23
[deleted] 7
- The intent still doesn't justify the action, in my opinion. -- nm - JaxSean Mar 3, 10:16 5
  - I think the question of justification is irrelevant once the action has taken its course. -- nm - znufrii, older, no wiser Mar 3, 10:20 4
    - *Marvels that he is agreeing with Znu* -- nm - Dr.Vermin Mar 3, 10:21 3
      - *braces for quantum singularity* -- nm - Reagen Mar 3, 10:22
      - the only motive I can see for revealing is to be retributive, which I see being less than useful. -- nm - znufrii, older, no wiser Mar 3, 10:22 1
        
        In this conversation, it sounds like people are suggesting it would be "preventative", but I think they misread the original supposition. -- nm - Beryllium Mar 3, 10:26
- and truth be told, he didn't do all that great of a job of it, either... -- nm - znufrii, older, no wiser Mar 3, 10:16

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.