ST Alpha - "Rage should win because they were artistically unique." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

In response to "OK, let's detail debate another matchup: Green Day vs. Rage Against The Machine." by TFox

Rage should win because they were artistically unique.

Posted by con_carne Mar 3 '09, 12:20

If Green Day wins, then why not any punk band who plays three chords? If GD wins, it's more a testament to their album sales, rather than their artistry/quality.

Responses:

Then my dof should win because when the radio comes on he goes nuts. - Loyola Mar 3, 12:23 1
- dog even -- nm - Loyola Mar 3, 12:24
Then I hereby nominate GWAR. -- nm - Spawn Mar 3, 12:22 4
- Rage were probably the single most influential band of the nineties. Not every day a music genre gets born. -- nm - con_carne Mar 3, 12:27 3
  - Nirvana? -- nm - Strongbad Mar 3, 12:28 2
    - I don't know that I can count nearly as many bands who copied their sound though -- nm - con_carne Mar 3, 12:33 1
      - I can't think of many "rock" bands in the 90s that didn't copy their sound. -- nm - Trish Mar 3, 12:34

Post a message top

Rage should win because they were artistically unique.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.