ST Alpha - "We know exactly what he is. He is a 21-year-old kid telling Matt Williams what his lineup would be. " (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 158

We know exactly what he is. He is a 21-year-old kid telling Matt Williams what his lineup would be.

Posted by David (aka David) Jul 1 '14, 08:28

This kid needs to be humbled to have a chance to be great.

Responses:

Well, i'm not sure I'd really consider Matt Williams right all the time after he nailed harper for not hustling while he was hurt - Hunta Jul 1, 08:32 9
- I'll take the judgment of a guy who has been in MLB since the 80s over one who has been in the majors since 2012 any day of the week. - David Jul 1, 08:41 8
  - I don't agree with Harper....but I also ain't going to say it's without merit. - Hunta Jul 1, 08:44 3
    - It is and I said as much when it happened. The other aspect is that Williams was brought in to be hard on Harper and teach him how to be great. - David Jul 1, 08:48 2
      - You can be tough on a player with freedom, but when you Kirk Gibson a guy who's hurt and actually taking it easy...that's just reinforcing that gulf. - Hunta Jul 1, 08:50 1
        
        That IM is a huge problem although I suspect it's not true. -- nm - David Jul 1, 08:53
  - while it is not ideal, he was asked his opinion, and he gave it. - groiny Jul 1, 08:42 3
    - His opinion should be, "I am just a player. Whatever my manager wants is what I will do." - David Jul 1, 08:44 2
      - if everyone answered that way, there would be no need for Sports reporting. nm -- nm - groiny Jul 1, 08:46 1
        
        wouldn't that be something. -- nm - Reagen Jul 1, 08:51
because that is what Bonds needed to be great. - groiny Jul 1, 08:29 15
- If you want the kid to be Ty Cobb, Ricky Henderson or Barry Bonds, that's your call. -- nm - David Jul 1, 08:30 14
  - well, the only thing keeping him from being great is him running into walls and diving head first into bases. - groiny Jul 1, 08:31 11
    - We'll see. Thus far, he's a 4 WAR player that people treat like an 8. - David Jul 1, 08:38 9
      - he is everything that Heyward was supposed to be. - groiny Jul 1, 08:40 8
        
        Heyward is 4 WAR as well yet you have soured on him... -- nm - David Jul 1, 08:42 7
        
        Heyward's WAR is inflated heavily from his rookie year; 5 years and it's basically 35% of his career mark. - Hunta Jul 1, 08:48 2
        
        See below... -- (link) - David Jul 1, 08:49 1
        
        His WAR this year, (while top 5) is broken down this way (Off. 1.0 - Def. 2.3 - Other .4) - Hunta Jul 1, 08:57
        
        he underperformed last year, he is underperforming this year. - groiny Jul 1, 08:43 3
        
        We -just- had the discussion yesterday of how he is top 5 in WAR. - David Jul 1, 08:47 2
        
        his attitude does not have any impact whatsoever on his on field play. - groiny Jul 1, 08:51 1
        
        It matters in helping your team win or lose. Teams are not as loose when they play with assholes. - David Jul 1, 08:52
    - [deleted]
  - [deleted] 1
    - And yet... -- nm - David Jul 1, 08:31

Post a message top

We know exactly what he is. He is a 21-year-old kid telling Matt Williams what his lineup would be.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.