ST Alpha - "I wasn't arguing the good or bad of PFF ratings. Just pointing out that they're opinion mixed with raw numbers." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 152

In response to "Inigo, those are professionally scouted grades based on every snap. " by David

I wasn't arguing the good or bad of PFF ratings. Just pointing out that they're opinion mixed with raw numbers.

Posted by Inigo (aka Inigo) Aug 4 '14, 08:24

And that opinion (the eye test) is what separates Cutler from Dalton. I'm glad that PFF can quantify the eye test with a number, and enjoy what they do, but it's still weighted in some way by personal opinion.

Responses:

Independent of that statement, the results still provide a professional grade of 10.43 per season to Cutler as opposed to 1.83 to Dalton. -- nm - David Aug 4, 08:28 2
- This would also be true had they won in January. -- nm - Will Hunting Aug 4, 08:33 1
  - There's also that. Cutler has won a playoff game. Dalton has not. -- nm - Inigo Aug 4, 08:34

Post a message top

I wasn't arguing the good or bad of PFF ratings. Just pointing out that they're opinion mixed with raw numbers.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.