ST Alpha - "I disagree. (spoiler)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 151

In response to "The how of it. spoil" by Spawn

I disagree. (spoiler)

Posted by nubby Aug 29 '14, 22:03

I guess I don't understand your quibble. What does it matter? Is there something more he could have done in the book?
Point is, either way, he did everything technically right, but she still died. Her death rests SOLELY on his decision to continue the relationship.

Show Spoilers

Responses:

The difference is between "if I hadn't known her, she'd be alive" and - TWuG Aug 30, 07:11 2
- Are you forgetting? (movie spoils)... - Inigo Aug 30, 07:59
- hmm. -- nm - kelly Aug 30, 07:33
it's a big difference. Spawn is right. -- nm - Peglegpete Aug 29, 22:15 3
- Never, ever say that about anything. Even if he is right -- nm - amoxy Aug 29, 22:16 2
  - you know the odds of him being right again are more than astronomical :) -- nm - Peglegpete Aug 29, 22:17 1
    - Never tell me the odds! -- nm - Spawn Aug 29, 23:21

Post a message top

I disagree. (spoiler)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.