ST Alpha - "That was the most consistent, highest quality season of Doctor Who thus far." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 150

That was the most consistent, highest quality season of Doctor Who thus far.

Posted by David (aka David) Dec 26 '14, 07:31

Still not in love with super-intense Doctor but that was a ton of high level sci-fi.

Responses:

Capaldi terrific, Coleman was great this year, she was really written for very well. Some of the stories themselves though were lacking... - Remlik Dec 26, 09:30
Said a guy once who had never seen Doctor Who before. -- nm - Mop Dec 26, 07:51 8
- My real concern is that Capaldi is going to take the blame. I really like him. -- nm - Mop Dec 26, 08:22 7
  - This thread hadme wondering so I looked. - David Dec 26, 08:30 6
    - I think this is a product of fans being new to Sci Fi as a genre. - TWuG Dec 26, 08:36 5
      - Ridley Scott and Dan O'Bannon should sue over last night's episode - amoxy Dec 26, 08:41 4
        
        Meh. There was a direct reference to Alien in the episode. It was self-aware. -- nm - Mop Dec 26, 11:09 2
        
        Spoils - TWuG Dec 26, 12:45 1
        
        "I think this is a product of fans being new to Sci Fi as a genre... I've been immersed in sci-fi for 40 years." - Ultron Dec 26, 13:22
        
        As skags liked to point out, everything has been done before. If they do something new with it and do it well, that is good. In addition, this episode - Ultron Dec 26, 09:15
You are nuts. Those stories were, for the most part, shit. -- nm - TWuG Dec 26, 07:36 10
- I would grade the episodes as follows... - David Dec 26, 07:58 6
  - Kill the Moon was one of the stupidest things I have ever watched. Beyond stupid. - TWuG Dec 26, 08:14 3
    - Wow, Kill the Moon is up there with Strange Wine for me. - David Dec 26, 08:18 2
      - "The Moon is an egg that hatches and is promptly replaced by amotger egg" is either someyhing you can - TWuG Dec 26, 08:31 1
        
        "between Clara and Danny" -- nm - TWuG Dec 26, 08:32
  - Kim scores as 3 good, 10 great, zero weak. - David Dec 26, 08:04
  - A post-Christmas miracle! - Ultron Dec 26, 08:03
- yeah, I've got to agree with TWuG on this one. -- nm - decline Dec 26, 07:36 2
  - Me, too -- nm - Covington Dec 26, 07:48 1
    - *gets popcorn* -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 26, 07:48

Post a message top

That was the most consistent, highest quality season of Doctor Who thus far.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.