ST Alpha - "She's mostly slagged for her entire catalog being based on her failed relationships. -- (edited)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 158

She's mostly slagged for her entire catalog being based on her failed relationships. -- (edited)

Posted by Shaun (aka bigshaunu) Jul 17 '15, 09:38

Which are probably here fault because I think she's probably batshit crazy in real life.

Responses:

[deleted] 17
- The difference here is that it's not just songs about break-ups, etc., it's about specific people and it's pretty widely known who each song is about. - pmb Jul 17, 09:46 14
  - can't you say the same about Pink? -- nm - groiny Jul 17, 09:51 11
    - Has Pink written about more than one person (that we know who they are?) I know there are songs about her husband, that's it. -- (edited) - Andie Jul 17, 09:54 9
      - she pretty much did a whole album about him being an ass IIRC. - groiny Jul 17, 09:55 8
        
        So did Marvin Gaye, and it was awesome! -- nm - Roger More Jul 17, 10:05
        
        I love her too, but she's married and still married. Yes, writing about personal stuff is fine and it's not hard to draw the lines of what is about - pmb Jul 17, 09:59 6
        
        [deleted] 1
        
        Not at all what I meant. The married part was just reflecting the fact that of course we know who that is about since she's with the same guy. It's - pmb Jul 17, 10:35
        
        And I should add, it makes her seem vindictive and a hot mess as well. -- nm - pmb Jul 17, 10:00 3
        
        for sure, but keep in mind, she is very young still. nm -- nm - groiny Jul 17, 10:02 2
        
        It doesn't really bother me that much and frankly I think she's growing out of it. I think she's proven to be an impressive businesswoman. - pmb Jul 17, 10:05
        
        she has a billion producers and managers etc who could temper that, but it sells, so they don't. -- nm - Andie Jul 17, 10:02
    - Pink gets huge props for never lip synching. -- nm - Shaun Jul 17, 09:54
  - [deleted] 1
    - Regarding the writing of the albums, there is a combination of information that backs it up. First they are credited to her along with Max Martin and - pmb Jul 17, 09:56
- Ha ha, I had a discussion with Coolio the other day about whether those sort of songs were how guys felt in real life. (I said, of course!) -- nm - Roger More Jul 17, 09:44
- On a serious note, her stuff is pretty good overall, even if it's all about the same shit. -- nm* - Shaun Jul 17, 09:40
And her real estate purchases. -- nm - Roger More Jul 17, 09:39 3
- See my IM. -- nm - Shaun Jul 17, 09:40 2
  - examples were needed! -- nm - Roger More Jul 17, 09:42 1
    - Indeed! -- nm - Shaun Jul 17, 09:43

Post a message top

She's mostly slagged for her entire catalog being based on her failed relationships. -- (edited)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.