ST Alpha - "i hear this argument and it's a cop out. if Lucas had said "well, i don't have to really give a shit about telling Star Wars well because it's really" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

In response to "SW:tFA A- It was a good representation of the best of the franchise and sets things up nicely to go in expanded directions. Also we finished Fargo" by Mel Profit

i hear this argument and it's a cop out. if Lucas had said "well, i don't have to really give a shit about telling Star Wars well because it's really

Posted by humbug (aka chris) Dec 21 '15, 08:27

just a set up for the GOOD second and third chapters!" it would have been equally lazy and poorly-written

Responses:

That was my one question to people that saw it before seeing it. (spoilers) - Obi-Wan Kilobi Dec 21, 09:05
I await your triumph in script writing. -- nm - Mel Profit Dec 21, 08:32 2
- Dude. -- nm - David Dec 21, 09:26
- as do i -- nm - humbug Dec 21, 08:33
Your handle is *pefect*. - Spawn Dec 21, 08:29 8
- i gave it a B - humbug Dec 21, 08:30 6
  - It was no Carol. -- nm - Spawn Dec 21, 08:34 5
    - i'm not the only one who's saying this -- (link) - humbug Dec 21, 08:35 4
      - Several of those are "questions to be explained" rather than plot-holes, IMO. - who's scruffy-looking? Dec 21, 08:54
      - I quit reading after the first two as they are utterly wrong. -- nm - Spawn Dec 21, 08:37 2
        
        the second one is egregiously incorrect. -- nm - Black Ops Deevs Dec 21, 08:54 1
        
        Yup. As I said on BBs spoils - Spawn Solo Dec 21, 08:56
- we're going to have to hear about how bad a storyteller JJ Abrams is for the reST of our lives. -- nm - Black Ops Deevs Dec 21, 08:30

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.