ST Alpha - "you just can't compare this to what Lucas did in 77, it is really apples and oranges." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 159

In response to "there was in Lucas's mind" by humbug

you just can't compare this to what Lucas did in 77, it is really apples and oranges.

Posted by Groindo (Green lives matter) (aka groiny) Dec 21 '15, 13:00

theatres did not want to touch Star Wars when it came out in 77.

Responses:

either you're trying to make the best possible movie you can at the time or you just say "eh, good enough for Disney" - humbug Dec 21, 13:02 7
- You can post that with a straight face? - Spawn Solo Dec 21, 13:08
- and I do not even totally disagree with some of your critiques of it. - Groindo (Green lives matter) Dec 21, 13:08
- it is different when you know you have 3 movies to make, or if you would like to make 3, but have to get buy in on 1 first. - Groindo (Green lives matter) Dec 21, 13:05 4
  - Yep. Every Star Wars fan now expects Star Wars movies from now until long after they are dead. - who's scruffy-looking? Dec 21, 13:11
  - Respectfully, I disagree -- nm - humbug Dec 21, 13:08 2
    - every trilogy ever made leaves questions unanswered. - Groindo (Green lives matter) Dec 21, 13:11 1
      - Clearly, we need to read one of pixie's trilogies. -- nm - Spawn Solo Dec 21, 13:16
Of course it is apples and oranges to pixie. The Holy Trilogy is good, everything else is bad. -- nm - Spawn Solo Dec 21, 13:01

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.