ST Alpha - "What grade would you give Man of Steel?" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

What grade would you give Man of Steel?

Posted by Loyola Mar 25 '16, 10:57

B+

Responses:

D- -- nm - Will Hunting Mar 25, 11:07
I believe I gave it a C. -- nm - colin Mar 25, 11:06
F. -- nm - TWuG Mar 25, 11:05 7
- lmao -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:06 6
  - I was apologizing to my wife and daughter for taking them to see it before it even left Krypton. They still give me shit for taking them. - TWuG Mar 25, 11:08 5
    - it is a much different tone, I would not expect my kids to like it. -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:10 4
      - Tone wasn't the issue. Spectacle over substance, crappy writting, stupid characters... all those were issues. -- nm - TWuG Mar 25, 11:12 3
        
        kids and adults have a different perspective. they dont understand all that shit. - groiny Mar 25, 11:14 2
        
        I'll tell my daughter her criticisms were invalid because she was too young to understand the words she was using. -- nm - TWuG Mar 25, 11:17 1
        
        *shrug* - groiny Mar 25, 11:18
C- -- nm - Max Mar 25, 11:04
C- -- nm - Radar from M*A*S*H Mar 25, 11:04
Those low grades are surprising. I don't even like most superhero movies; - Loyola Mar 25, 11:04 21
- Maybe you just have shit taste in superhero movies... -- nm - Ender Mar 25, 11:10 5
  - maybe superhero movies are just a shit genre.. - colin Mar 25, 11:11 4
    - the box office numbers disagree with you -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:12 3
      - considering how much actual shit Card Against Humanity sold for black friday that one time, I wouldn't use commercial success as my only standard.... -- nm - znufrii Mar 25, 11:15
      - Minions is also one of the top grossing movies of all time. And McDonalds hamburgers are one of the best selling food items of all time. - colin Mar 25, 11:14 1
        
        this is why I think critics are out of touch -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:21
- IM 2 was pretty good. -- nm - colin Mar 25, 11:07 7
  - I didn't like it much but that could have been because of my expectations. -- nm - Krusty Mar 25, 11:18
  - If it comes to netflix I'll rewatch it. But I wouldn't call it great. - Beryllium Mar 25, 11:09 3
    - the car chase scene alone is enough reason to rewatch Matrix Reloaded. -- nm - colin Mar 25, 11:10
    - matrix 2 is also garbage -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:10 1
      - You are garbage! -- nm - Shaun Mar 25, 11:11
  - and this is where you lost my vote - groiny Mar 25, 11:09 1
    - cinematically, it's quite nice. Favreau really knows his craft. That for me really helped the movie a lot. -- nm - colin Mar 25, 11:10
- your IM is not gonna win you any elections. -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 11:05 6
  - Thor was pretty good though. -- nm - Loyola Mar 25, 11:07 5
    - Winter Soldier is one of the best comic movies ever. - groiny Mar 25, 11:08 4
      - See, we can agree on movies. Cap 2 was everything MoS should have been. -- nm - TWuG Mar 25, 11:13 2
        
        it is not that I dont think we can agree.... - groiny Mar 25, 11:16 1
        
        We obviously put different levels of importance on what pissed me off. The very essence of the character was lost, Imo - TWuG Mar 25, 11:22
      - I would put it #2 behind Dark Knight. Love it. -- nm - Will Hunting Mar 25, 11:11
C- -- nm - Ender Mar 25, 11:02
B+, I liked it. -- nm - Krusty Mar 25, 11:01
D+ -- nm - David Mar 25, 11:00
Z- -- nm - Twug Mar 25, 11:00 1
- I stick to traditional grading scales, but out of 100 it'd get about a 30. -- nm - TWuG Mar 25, 11:06
B+ Much better than Thor: The Dark World -- nm - crash davis Mar 25, 11:00 2
- If MoS is a B+ for you, BvS should be an A for sure, IMO. -- nm - Shaun Mar 25, 11:01 1
  - all right! -- nm - crash davis Mar 25, 11:03
B -- nm - Shaun Mar 25, 10:58
B -- nm - ML Mar 25, 10:58
I give it a B. -- nm - groiny Mar 25, 10:57
dogshit -- nm - pixie ninja Mar 25, 10:57
F(AIL) -- nm - Spawn Mar 25, 10:57

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.