ST Alpha - "ST Opinion: How good was Rogue One, compared to Ep 7? Better, worse or about the same? -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

ST Opinion: How good was Rogue One, compared to Ep 7? Better, worse or about the same? -- nm

Posted by Strongbad (aka Rambler14) Apr 12 '17, 09:08

(No message)

Responses:

I have no idea how to answer - I have to struggle to tell you what 7 was about - Rogue One stuck with me -- nm - Epiphany Apr 12, 09:37
Rogue One B- or C+. Force Awakens - A -- nm - Inigo Apr 12, 09:24
"How good was" and "How much did you enjoy" are pretty interesting ways of looking at this (that I had not noticed). - Spawn Apr 12, 09:23
I think I liked Rogue 1 a bit more than SW7, some of the things in SW7 felt forced. - groiny Apr 12, 09:23
For me it ranks #3 (after Empire and New Hope) -- nm - Jovian Apr 12, 09:20
It was better than EP7-- -- nm - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:14
I liked Ep 7 but Rogue One was more my favorite. It might be my 2nd favorite SW movie. The fact that they made the audience... - Mel Profit Apr 12, 09:12 12
- In case that was a spoil, sorry. -- (edited) - Spawn Apr 12, 09:13 11
  - that inclusion was great, however, I've mulled over how it could have been better. (R1 Spoilers) - Mel Profit Apr 12, 09:16 8
    - All I can say is they sure as hell better have a great script for the Solo Cup movie. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:18 1
      - Rogue One just showed how dumb/selfish Lucas was--let other people run with their SW ideas...you reap the rewards -- nm - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:35
    - Agreed. But wouldn't it be fun if this was a lead-in to us learning (spoilers) - ty97 Apr 12, 09:18 5
      - I'm not sure he understood the significance of (spoilers) - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:25 1
        
        Yeah, the theory that he just realize the significance could be. -- nm - ty97 Apr 12, 09:26
      - Not ridic, as that is my fall back theory as well. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:19 2
        
        Spoilers -- (edited) - ty97 Apr 12, 09:23 1
        
        Yeah, I think the worst thing Vader could be was idle. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:25
  - I'll help you out (spoils) - Will Hunting Apr 12, 09:15 1
    - Eh spoil - Spawn Apr 12, 09:17
I preferred Rogue One because it was new. Episode 7, while I still liked it, felt like the episode 4 script with new people. -- nm* - volnelk Apr 12, 09:11 1
- I think EP7 got corrupted when Harrison Ford got hurt--rewrites, reproaches...it became a soft reboot, instead of a direct sequel -- nm - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:29
haven't seen it -- nm - decline Apr 12, 09:09 1
- Same. -- nm - Krusty Apr 12, 09:24
I like Ep 7 more, probably in part because it was part of the 'series of 9' and also nostalgia. - ty97 Apr 12, 09:08 1
- Yeah, I would say RO was maybe 90% as good. But I have still not seen it a second time. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:11

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.