ST Alpha - "I liked Ep 7 but Rogue One was more my favorite. It might be my 2nd favorite SW movie. The fact that they made the audience..." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

In response to "ST Opinion: How good was Rogue One, compared to Ep 7? Better, worse or about the same? -- nm" by Strongbad

I liked Ep 7 but Rogue One was more my favorite. It might be my 2nd favorite SW movie. The fact that they made the audience...

Posted by Mel Profit (aka mel profit) Apr 12 '17, 09:12

care about characters we didn't previously know means they were successful in writing a good story. The last 45mins is intense.

Responses:

In case that was a spoil, sorry. -- (edited) - Spawn Apr 12, 09:13 11
- that inclusion was great, however, I've mulled over how it could have been better. (R1 Spoilers) - Mel Profit Apr 12, 09:16 8
  - All I can say is they sure as hell better have a great script for the Solo Cup movie. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:18 1
    - Rogue One just showed how dumb/selfish Lucas was--let other people run with their SW ideas...you reap the rewards -- nm - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:35
  - Agreed. But wouldn't it be fun if this was a lead-in to us learning (spoilers) - ty97 Apr 12, 09:18 5
    - I'm not sure he understood the significance of (spoilers) - Flavorize Apr 12, 09:25 1
      - Yeah, the theory that he just realize the significance could be. -- nm - ty97 Apr 12, 09:26
    - Not ridic, as that is my fall back theory as well. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:19 2
      - Spoilers -- (edited) - ty97 Apr 12, 09:23 1
        
        Yeah, I think the worst thing Vader could be was idle. - Spawn Apr 12, 09:25
- I'll help you out (spoils) - Will Hunting Apr 12, 09:15 1
  - Eh spoil - Spawn Apr 12, 09:17

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.