ST Alpha - "I'd probably vote for McNabb." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

In response to "He is Dallas's Donovan McNabb who is also not a HOFer -- nm" by rollo

I'd probably vote for McNabb.

Posted by Da5id (aka David) Apr 12 '17, 10:18

He's like 51/49. I'd actually call McNabb the line of demarcation for a HoF QB. He's barely on one side of it or the other.

Responses:

that's fair -- nm - rollo Apr 12, 10:26
For me, it's Warner of the modern ilk. - Will Hunting Apr 12, 10:20 13
- Warner got in the Hall of Fame this year. - Da5id Apr 12, 10:23 12
  - Warner would be my in/out line. - Will Hunting Apr 12, 10:26 11
    - That's bs. Every single fucking time Tom Brady leads a game winning drive, he's the most clutch QB of all time. - Shaun Apr 12, 10:28 10
      - In an alternate universe, one of those required the receiver to catch the curved ball with his helmet which is another curved surface. -- (edited) - Mel Profit Apr 12, 10:46 2
        
        Oh it happened! Let me find a link! -- (link*) - Shaun Apr 12, 10:53 [youtube] 1
        
        This is like Man in the High Castle shit...did not happen. - Mel Profit Apr 12, 10:55
      - When Team #1 averages 35 points per game and the final score is 17-14...I'm not giving the winning QB all that much credit. - Will Hunting Apr 12, 10:33 6
        
        You might not, but the voters decided he was the game's MVP. -- nm - Da5id Apr 12, 10:46 5
        
        I think most voters were loathe to split their votes 4-ways. - Will Hunting Apr 12, 10:52 2
        
        You can use that 'but, if' clause for every single game in the history of sports. It's a shit argument. - Shaun Apr 12, 10:58 1
        
        But, if....I'm not arguing who won -- the Giants won (and deserved to) - Will Hunting Apr 12, 11:04
        
        But David he didn't do anything useful. He was just there for shits n giggs and was useless. - Shaun Apr 12, 10:51 1
        
        I'm sorry I dared to insinuate your QB who only scored 17 points (7 of which are due to an outright miracle play) - Will Hunting Apr 12, 10:57

Post a message top

I'd probably vote for McNabb.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.