ST Alpha - "He's not good enough to build the entire team around. (And that style has been flawed in recent years.)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

In response to "There is a small point to be made about his style bring difficult to accommodate" by Reagen

He's not good enough to build the entire team around. (And that style has been flawed in recent years.)

Posted by Name Withheld by Request (aka BlueKopo) Sep 25 '17, 13:27

I think he's a borderline guy already with the politics being used as the tie-breaker in the decision whether to sign him or not.

Who's the best style equivalent right now? Carolina making the Super Bowl a couple of years ago?

Responses:

Ron Jaworski, one of the most respected game film analysts, believes he has the talent to be the best QB ever. -- nm - David Sep 25, 13:56 6
- I like Jaws and that praise carries enough weight that it would give me pause, but five seasons haven't backed it up. - Name Withheld by Request Sep 25, 13:59 5
  - See below. His game film isn't middling. Under a good NFL coach, he was a championship caliber QB. -- nm - David Sep 25, 14:01 4
    - Okay, okay, okay. That's fair. Not definitive because Eli's a two-time Super Bowl champ, but fair. -- nm - Name Withheld by Request Sep 25, 14:03 3
      - Eli has started every game of his NFL career. Keep is currently unemployed. -- nm - David Sep 25, 14:05 2
        
        The New York Giants weren't about to turf their franchise QB this season to go with Kaep. -- (edited) - Name Withheld by Request Sep 25, 14:06 1
        
        In the market for a starter? No. In the market for viable QBs? Absolutely. - David Sep 25, 14:10
Marcus Mariota and DeShaun Watson - Reagen Sep 25, 13:34 5
- I guess I was looking for team success as a metric for the system style, but I suppose. - Name Withheld by Request Sep 25, 13:55 3
  - Michael Vick average 42 ypg rushing and 56% passing. And killed dogs. (And got hired by 3 teams after that). - Will Hunting Sep 25, 14:01 1
    - That's kind of a chilling distilled evaluation. -- nm - David Sep 25, 14:14
  - Keep led his team to two conference title games and was an eyelash away from a Super Bowl win. -- nm* - David Sep 25, 13:58
- Watson was friggin' sublime yesterday. -- nm - Diva Sep 25, 13:36
Joe Webb just got signed a week or two ago. - Will Hunting Sep 25, 13:32

Post a message top

He's not good enough to build the entire team around. (And that style has been flawed in recent years.)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.