ST Alpha - "Good poll question on Dan Patrick. As an NFL player would you rather make the HOF with no rings, or win two Superbowls with no HOF? -- (edited)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

Good poll question on Dan Patrick. As an NFL player would you rather make the HOF with no rings, or win two Superbowls with no HOF? -- (edited)

Posted by Volnelk Nov 22 '17, 07:35

And not just ride the coattails to a ring. I mean win the Super Bowl because of you.

Essentially would you rather have Randy Moss or Julian Edelman’s career?

Responses:

Hall of Fame. The list of greats who don't have a title is long. HoF is eternal. - Will Hunting Nov 22, 09:22
Rings. assuming the pay is the same for career earnings. I see it more of Marino vs Eli -- nm - Beaker Nov 22, 08:00 2
- Eli is making the HOF. - Strongbad Nov 22, 08:05 1
  - I agree with that -- nm - Bacon Nov 22, 08:06
Superbowl. -- nm - Name Withheld by Request Nov 22, 07:58
HOF. You get to hang with those guys every year. It's a position that enhances your life forever. -- nm - Bacon Nov 22, 07:38 6
- But with the CTE, you will not remember any of them. -- nm - Spawn Nov 22, 07:49 5
  - But I also wouldn't remember you win win... OH BURN!! -- nm* - Bacon (Channeling my inner Pixie) Nov 22, 07:50 4
    - A Super Bowl win means an entire season of winning. So I would rather have two years of that than a career of good play, but not winning. -- nm - Spawn Nov 22, 07:54 3
      - I want to eat dinner every year with all the HOFers, get to vote every year for HOFers, and get announced as here I Bacon NFL Hall of Famer - Bacon (channeling my inner Pixie) Nov 22, 08:00 2
        
        the other QBs would mock you for your ringless hands -- nm - Beaker Nov 22, 08:02 1
        
        An important part of this poll is the fact that you would *not* be a QB. Which actually does add a little weight to the HOF side of it. -- nm - Spawn Nov 22, 08:10
Rings. -- nm - Eli Nov 22, 07:37
Two Super Bowl rings. -- nm - Krusty Nov 22, 07:35 1
- Yup. One? I would probably go HOF. But two or more? Give me the bling. -- nm - Spawn Nov 22, 07:50

Post a message top

Good poll question on Dan Patrick. As an NFL player would you rather make the HOF with no rings, or win two Superbowls with no HOF? -- (edited)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.