ST Alpha - "Geno Smith is probably better than Manning anyway. Manning is the most over rated QB in modern history. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 166

Geno Smith is probably better than Manning anyway. Manning is the most over rated QB in modern history. -- nm

Posted by CQ (aka CQ) Nov 29 '17, 05:02

(No message)

Responses:

Child please -- nm - ty97 Nov 29, 05:40
he's properly rated as a good/very good QB with 2 rings who shouldn't make the HOF. -- nm* - Beaker Nov 29, 05:34
Manning is overrated; Geno Smith is not better than him. - Will Hunting Nov 29, 05:16 7
- This. Manning isn't close to being his brother but he's significantly better than Geno and many of the guys playing QB in the league. -- nm* - Krusty Nov 29, 06:02
- It's like McAdoo had a Brewster's Millions type bet with someone to see how fast he could lose games and lose the team's trust in him. -- nm - Inigo Nov 29, 05:19 4
  - I'm not even an Eli fan, but this is absurd. - Will Hunting Nov 29, 05:45 2
    - agreed (and with Diva below). -- nm - Beaker Nov 29, 06:34
    - Agreed. I'm annoyed with the move and I don't care a lick for the Giants. -- nm - Krusty Nov 29, 06:04
  - He thought the Bills benching Tyrod was awesome and was all like, 'Hold my beer...'. -- nm - Diva Nov 29, 05:43
- yeah, heh. -- nm - CQ Nov 29, 05:17
Based on history, pretty much everyone knows not true. Man has SB wins. But a 2-9 record kinda puts one in full evaluation mode. Draft pick -- nm - budice Nov 29, 05:04 8
- It's a team game. While the QB is the most integral part of a team, the Giants didn't win their SBs through their offense imo. Super Bowl wins do not - CQ Nov 29, 05:07 7
  - Hot takes are the worst takes. -- nm - David Nov 29, 06:43
  - I wouldn't call it luck. He was aces during those two Super Bowl runs. - Inigo Nov 29, 05:16 4
    - The defense was aces during those 2 runs. They were insane. -- nm - CQ Nov 29, 05:21 3
      - This is a no win argument for you... -- nm - J Nov 29, 05:39
      - His stat line for those two runs: 15 TDs, 2073 yds, 2 INTs, 4 fourth qtr comebacks, 5 game winning drives in 8 games. - Inigo Nov 29, 05:28 1
        
        That's awful. Just awful. - ceeque Nov 29, 06:58
  - He's an average QB over his career who got lucky as shit twice. -- nm - CQ Nov 29, 05:08

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.