ST Alpha - "So the definition of "something" in this case is A) Reviving the dead or B) Going back in time to prevent it? -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 159

In response to "are any of those 49 people going to be not-dead? -- nm" by Andie

So the definition of "something" in this case is A) Reviving the dead or B) Going back in time to prevent it? -- nm

Posted by Strongbad (aka Rambler14) Mar 15 '19, 05:56

(No message)

Responses:

C) Actually doing something to stop this from happening in the future instead of praying and talking about how you'd - Krusty Mar 15, 06:04
I read it as "let's take some type of actual action to hopefully prevent this type of tragedy, instead of the typical 'thoughts and prayers.'" -- nm - JaxSean Mar 15, 05:59
or, you know, stopping it from happening again. - Andie Mar 15, 05:57
[deleted] 36
- Let's just accept the original message for what it is. - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:01 35
  - James 2:26 "For as the body without spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also." - oblique Mar 15, 06:10 3
    - I think the other key difference here - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:59 1
      - fair -- nm - Beaker Mar 15, 07:00
    - Thanks for this. - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:16
  - I mean, if you are going to just invent something preposterous and put it in her mouth, why not imply she was saying something like - Marlowe Mar 15, 06:08
  - uh, that's really not what she's saying -- nm - decline Mar 15, 06:05
  - That's not it at all. It's just that a lot of us want actual action on this issue and all we get are thoughts and prayers. -- nm - Krusty Mar 15, 06:05
  - That's not it AT ALL. Many of us have been saying for a long time that thoughts and prayers are *not enough*. - ty97 Mar 15, 06:04 23
    - You really don't think it's a leap from - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:13 21
      - My hope is that those offering thoughts and prayers are actually thinking about it and praying for an answer as well. - JaxSean Mar 15, 06:24 1
        
        I agree. -- nm - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:35
      - I think it's more that the term "thoughts and prayers" needs to be retired. It's not helpful anymore. -- nm* - Inigo Mar 15, 06:24 1
        
        Which is sad, because this was a thing long before Politicization of Everything began. -- nm - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:25
      - [deleted] 4
        
        I am admittedly overly sensitive to people showing possible prejudice against people with religious beliefs. Always will, that's who I am. - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:24 3
        
        [deleted] 2
        
        I am an imperfect being with many faults. -- nm - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:45 1
        
        Aren’t we all. -- nm - Super Daddy Princess Mar 15, 06:53
      - In practical terms, how is the second statement wrong, in regards to preventing another occurrence? - Super Daddy Princess Mar 15, 06:18 5
        
        Because you're limiting the context of this discussion only to preventing another occurrence. - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:21 4
        
        The politicians she is criticizing are limiting the discussion in the exact opposite way, which is the point I think she is making. -- (edited) - Super Daddy Princess Mar 15, 06:29
        
        You could fill a whole hour of TV with politicians offering thoughts and prayers after horrors like this occurred. And then append 60 seconds of black - ty97 Mar 15, 06:24 1
        
        Agree 100%. -- nm - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:31
        
        i just don't see it the way you do. the whole TAPS response is her target. -- nm - Andie Mar 15, 06:22
      - [deleted] 4
        
        Personally, I believe that my 2nd statement is a pretty demeaning thing to say to someone of any religion. -- nm - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:18 3
        
        Question: With all the thoughts and prayers that have been given over the past decade, has anything improved? No one is saying don't do that. She - Andie Mar 15, 06:20 2
        
        And again, that's great if that was her intent. - Strongbad Mar 15, 06:29 1
        
        Good, as in a material good, in the sense of preventing future incidents of this type. - Reagen Mar 15, 06:40
      - see kilbo's note above. -- nm - Andie Mar 15, 06:16
    - I mean, I prayed for the victims and their loved ones last night. I think praying for them is a great thing! - ty97 Mar 15, 06:05
  - [deleted]
  - No, that’s not it at all. -- nm - Super Daddy Princess Mar 15, 06:03
  - yes, let's take it at face value. prayers are NOT going to help if nothing else is done. if prayer helps you, that is wonderful. Then when you leave - Andie Mar 15, 06:03
  - I don't get that at all. -- nm - Beaker Mar 15, 06:02

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.