|
In response to
"If you look at WAR and JAWS to compare them against their peers all of them are in. "
by
spamlet
|
Total numbers for all of them aren't where they need to be to get into the hall. I went through each guy and compared them to guys already in and
|
their contemporaries and they fall short.
Abreu collected stats over a long career with few injuries but still didn't get 3k hits or 500 hrs. I can ignore that and I still think he falls short.
I said why I think Hudson and Buehrle fall short. They had some great years and big games but for their careers their numbers aren't HoF worthy. I do recognize that their numbers are inflated due to the rampant cheating around the league. They're both close but if I had a vote I would likely only vote for Rolen
|