ST Alpha - "My unpopular Pixar take is that Up gets a higher ranking in people’s minds than it should just because of the first ten minutes. " (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

My unpopular Pixar take is that Up gets a higher ranking in people’s minds than it should just because of the first ten minutes.

Posted by Volnelk Jun 17 '21, 12:10

The beginning is sublime. The rest is ok.

Responses:

What the first ten minutes have taught me, bet the hand that your money's on - rollo Jun 17, 13:39
And Coco haters are insane. -- nm - znufrii Jun 17, 13:33
The first ten minutes are the best in Pixar (and many others)…the rest is a lot of fun. -- nm - Will Hunting Jun 17, 12:55
I rate it highly for the talking dog almost exclusively. -- nm - mara Jun 17, 12:40 2
- fantastic, really. -- nm - Spawn Jun 17, 12:48
- This. -- nm - Beryllium Jun 17, 12:42
I looooooove it all. Dug and Kevin. Russell and Carl. Christopher Plummer as a truly great villain. - Dark Callisto Jun 17, 12:38 1
- Yup. -- nm - kelly Jun 17, 12:53
Dug is fantastic. -- nm - Reagen Jun 17, 12:28
That might be the most sloppy bawl-inducing 4 minutes Pixar has ever produced. -- nm - Barontronic Jun 17, 12:21 3
- Sloppy? -- nm - JD Jun 17, 12:26 2
  - Sloppy cry, not sloppy filmmaking -- nm - TWuG Jun 17, 12:26 1
    - Correct. I was imprecise. The sloppy is in reference to the bawling. -- nm - Barontronic Jun 17, 12:38
That's actually what lowers it for me. That sequence is too emotional. The rest of it is a fun romp. -- nm - David Jun 17, 12:19 2
- That was what made the romp even better. -- nm - Spawn Jun 17, 12:25 1
  - Yeah, but ... I'm pretty sure being emotionally annihilated would reduce the fun. And it was more annihilating for some than others. -- nm - Beryllium Jun 17, 12:43
So, the first ten minutes don't count? -- nm - Spawn Jun 17, 12:11 1
- They do, but it isn’t a ten minute movie. So it’s ok. -- nm - Volnelk Jun 17, 12:24
and that alone is fine. Its up on my list too -- nm - budice Jun 17, 12:11

Post a message top

My unpopular Pixar take is that Up gets a higher ranking in people’s minds than it should just because of the first ten minutes.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.