ST Alpha - "For Star Wars, would you all agree that Ep 1-3 had a better artistic vision and execution than Ep 7-9? -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 165

For Star Wars, would you all agree that Ep 1-3 had a better artistic vision and execution than Ep 7-9? -- nm

Posted by Beryllium (aka grayman) Sep 14 '21, 08:53

(No message)

Responses:

yes -- nm - Beaker Sep 14, 09:10
Vision…yes. Execution…no. - Will Hunting Sep 14, 09:05 8
- So the execution of each individual film in 7-9 was good, but the overall vision was a dereliction of duty, you mean? -- nm - Beryllium Sep 14, 09:10 7
  - maybe this is it. (7 is my fave since the original 3) -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:15 6
    - I thought 7 was okay. Complete knock off of 4 but not bad. I loved 8’s potential. They immediately pretended it never happened and 9 was so meh - Will Hunting Sep 14, 09:25 1
      - yeah, exactly. -- nm - Beryllium Sep 14, 09:26
    - This thread reads a like a bit or something. Yes, 7 was great and clearly the best of 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9. - Spawn Sep 14, 09:19 2
      - forgettable? nah -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:21 1
        
        In comparison it is nearly. Look at it like this, where was the story at the end of 6 compared to the end of 9? Practically in the same exact place, except we know Luke, Han and Leia are dead, as well as their children. -- nm* - Spawn Sep 14, 09:23
    - I liked 7 and 8. But 9 purposefully undid all of the potential of those two. Made the whole exercise generic and conformist. -- nm - Beryllium Sep 14, 09:17
no -- nm - mud Sep 14, 08:56
Easily. -- nm - Spawn Sep 14, 08:56
Crap is crap. -- nm - David Sep 14, 08:56 11
- I'm trying to gauge if letting a creator run rampant on their own vision is superior to letting a corporation approach it cynically. -- nm - Beryllium Sep 14, 08:58 10
  - it depends on the creator. Lucas w/ 1-3 had a blurry vision dressed up in shiny crap. -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:14 8
    - Okay, how about Lana Wachowski? I'm betting that's going to be far sharper of a vision. -- nm - Beryllium Sep 14, 09:15 7
      - sure. We'll see. -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:17 6
        
        I think I'm the only one who thinks the Matrix 4 trailer portends of hot garbage -- nm - rollo Sep 14, 09:21 5
        
        I agree with you. -- nm - Will Hunting Sep 14, 09:26
        
        I think it was craftily put together so as not to reveal the true plot. - Beryllium Sep 14, 09:25
        
        I only watched once. It confused me, made me want to revisit 2 & 3 (I loved 2) -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:23 2
        
        I think I'll binge all 3 (Nflx) one day before 4 arrives! -- nm - mud Sep 14, 09:29 1
        
        The biggest problem I had with 3 is I thought it was a bad ending. But now, it was not the ending. So yeah, I look forward to re-watching, - Spawn Sep 14, 09:33
  - 7, 8 and 9 were all over the place. Add to that they were a retread of 4-6 and they get knocked below 1-3. -- nm - Spawn Sep 14, 09:00

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.