ST Alpha - "Best guess: Is the Harry Potter redeemable in the next five years?" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 165

Best guess: Is the Harry Potter redeemable in the next five years?

Posted by David (aka David) May 22 '22, 12:55

People will forgive at some point, but will it happen soon?

Responses:

I would think they could do Hogwarts: The Next Generation. - Max May 22, 17:29
If a new movie or book came out, with HP +JK involved, the rabid fans would be there. Any non-JK involvement and it gets ripped as non-canon -- (edited) - Flavorize May 22, 13:46 2
- I deeply disagree. The hardcore Potter fans are militantly LGBTQ+ friendly. There’s seem deep soul searching in the community. - Mop May 22, 15:06 1
  - I’ll say it doesn’t matter about her or Depp. The first movie in this series opened to 72mil. 15 years after the 1st Potter opened to far more - Will Hunting May 22, 15:15
Sure. If they get back to stories people care about. - Will Hunting May 22, 13:07 2
- It should have been Dumbledore based, from the first one. -- nm - Spawn May 22, 13:40 1
  - I haven’t seen any of the new but I agree. - Will Hunting May 22, 14:51
Maybe...if WB could cut a big enough check to get it out of her hands. -- nm - Remlik May 22, 13:04 2
- Yeah, this is the only end game that makes sense, but Warner Bros. just doesn’t have that kind of money to throw around right now. -- nm - Mop May 22, 15:07
- only if she pulled a george lucas or a notch, but I don't think she'd be interested in that. -- nm - Beryllium May 22, 13:05
If WB somehow convinces JKR to shut the eff up... But I agree that a film with HP himself would perform much better in any case. - Marlowe May 22, 13:02 1
- Yes, this. What is there to "forgive" when the person is still actively pursuing avenues of harm? -- nm - Beryllium May 22, 13:02
Cursed Child could film as a movie today and release next year without a problem -- nm - budice May 22, 12:57 3
- Except that it is a horrible story that never should have seen the light of day. It feels like ... - zork May 22, 15:58
- only with the original cast. -- nm - Remlik May 22, 13:03 1
  - Who have enough money that they never need to. -- nm - Reagen May 22, 14:53
... forgive what? -- nm - Beryllium May 22, 12:56

Post a message top

Best guess: Is the Harry Potter redeemable in the next five years?

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.