ST Alpha - "I think POA is my 2nd least favorite book of the series, but the 2nd best movie." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

I think POA is my 2nd least favorite book of the series, but the 2nd best movie.

Posted by Will Hunting (aka JoeMetz) Jul 16 '09, 08:43

I like #5's movie the most and the book the least so I wonder if it's more that they elminated the things I disliked most about the books in the transitions to film.

Responses:

I think Order of the Phoenix is the best of the films and the worst of the books. - Jim Jul 16, 08:47 6
- I think they condensed so much of GoF that it lost it's "Holy S**T!" build up that the book had. - Will Hunting Jul 16, 08:48 4
  - [deleted]
  - We could still see this tonight... -- nm - kelly Jul 16, 08:52 1
    - I'm game. -- nm - Will Hunting Jul 16, 08:52
  - I don't think it was possible to do Goblet of Fire justice in one movie. - Jim Jul 16, 08:49
- I agree with the subject -- nm - con_carne Jul 16, 08:48

Post a message top

I think POA is my 2nd least favorite book of the series, but the 2nd best movie.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.