ST Alpha - "But the logic still doesn't hold. (movie & book spoils)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 162

In response to "my impression" by mafic

But the logic still doesn't hold. (movie & book spoils)

Posted by Will Hunting (aka JoeMetz) Jul 21 '09, 09:23

Draco is the attacker; Snape is bound to complete the task; the other 4 are just going to observe in a highly protected castle?

The other 4 do absolutely nothing in the scene other than taunt Dumbledore, who's, in the movie, accepted his fate, in the book, he's protected Harry at the cost of his own protection.

It was so underwhelming in what should have been an epic scene; the death of the legend at the hands of his trusted sidekick.

Show Spoilers

Responses:

in the book... (SPOILERS) - Andie Jul 21, 09:36 7
- Yeah - Will Hunting Jul 21, 09:40 5
  - *spoils* - Ender Jul 21, 09:57
  - but - Andie Jul 21, 09:43 3
    - To me, that would only serve to make certain he'd fight back - Will Hunting Jul 21, 09:47
    - I'll refer you back to my post. - mafic Jul 21, 09:46 1
      - (this should be for Will. stupid excess of latin) -- nm - mafic Jul 21, 09:46
- it was. -- nm - tRuMaN Jul 21, 09:38
spoils - mafic Jul 21, 09:30 1
- Never once shone through to me in that sense. I don't buy it at all. - Will Hunting Jul 21, 09:31

Post a message top

But the logic still doesn't hold. (movie & book spoils)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.