ST Alpha - "doesn't Teh Analytics say that a player like Otani either (1) can't possibly exist or (2) is futile to try and actually fit on a roster? -- (link)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

doesn't Teh Analytics say that a player like Otani either (1) can't possibly exist or (2) is futile to try and actually fit on a roster? -- (link)

Posted by hollywood big shot (aka pickmix) Jun 28 '23, 02:20

(No message)

i'd probably try and find more Otanis if i were a dumb GM who ignored Teh Analytics (twitter.com)

Responses:

did your hatey for analytics arise because some of them tried to stretch into political forecasting? -- nm - crash davis 😺 Jun 28, 06:23
do... they? -- nm - Reagen Jun 28, 02:46 11
- if the Moneyballers thought a two-way player was such a value proposition we should have seen many more of them before Otani -- nm - hollywood big shot Jun 28, 02:53 10
  - I'm having difficulty responding to how nonsensical this is. - Reagen Jun 28, 03:21 9
    - no. there should be 100 guys hitting .300 with 40 hoe runs and throwing 300 k's a season. it is facts! -- nm - Beaker 🍺 Jun 28, 04:30 7
      - Hell, in another 20 years, there might be since these kids will have a real example of why not try both? - Will Hunting 🍔🍟🍔🍹🍷 Jun 28, 04:50 6
        
        Not that it's Old School Baseball's fault, because as you say, it's fucking hard. But they had 100 years to produce an Ohtani, and didn't - Reagen Jun 28, 05:05 3
        
        Teams and coaches prevented guys from trying to play both ways. Lots of guys grow up and go through HS playing a position and pitching. - Krusty Jun 28, 05:58 2
        
        And even then we're talking about someone who has Cy Young ability as a pitcher and MVP on his batting alone. -- nm* - Reagen Jun 28, 06:06 1
        
        I honestly believe we've had many guys that could do both at an elite level but were prevented from doing it. -- nm - Krusty Jun 28, 06:13
        
        it's why there aren't more Deion's or Bo Jacksons. To be elite you focus on one sport or part of the sport. Freaks can do more than one -- nm - Beaker 🍺 Jun 28, 04:54 1
        
        Teams discourage guys from being multi-sport athletes. They want them to focus on one sport. -- nm - Krusty Jun 28, 05:59
    - I mean they had a chance to hit once in every 9 batters for like 150 years. Teams didn't WANT a .095 AVG in that spot... - Ender Jun 28, 03:28

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.