ST Alpha - "i know. and it's dumb. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 157

In response to "actually..." by znufrii

i know. and it's dumb. -- nm

Posted by TFox Sep 17 '09, 07:20

(No message)

Responses:

why? -- nm - znufrii Sep 17, 07:22 19
- Because any amount is arbitrary and will likely be set up for a constitutional challenge before its even law. - Walt_Disney Sep 17, 07:25
- 1) harms smaller/non-media driven regions 2) creates a system where money-raising is the sole job of these people. - Will Hunting Sep 17, 07:23 17
  - if anything, I'd think a threshold neutralizes the fund-raising arms race, because once you have sufficient support, there is no further incentive - znufrii Sep 17, 07:31 7
    - Never leave it to chance. Run up the score every single moment. - Will Hunting Sep 17, 07:33 2
      - I just thought of the perfect disincentive for this. - znufrii Sep 17, 07:42 1
        
        So you'd throw out people who are clearly a choice of hundreds of thousands of people. - Will Hunting Sep 17, 07:47
    - Well, except to keep others under the threshold, and thereby give your own vote more power. -- nm - TFox Sep 17, 07:32 3
      - okay, I can see that being a valid concern. - znufrii Sep 17, 07:37 2
        
        you do not have to worry. it will never leave your own head,. -- nm - TFox Sep 17, 07:38 1
        
        I don't have any doubt about that -- nm - znufrii Sep 17, 07:40
  - and it also gets fucking Carrot Top and Fred Phelps elected, if you just need a viral Youtube video and 1,000 crazy fucks from anywhere to vote for yo -- nm - TFox Sep 17, 07:27 8
    - I was thinking more like 500,000 - znufrii Sep 17, 07:29 7
      - 500.....in a voting pool of 100million tops = at most 200 representatives. - Will Hunting Sep 17, 07:32 3
        
        i'm stopping now. every post i make, i realize it's akin to explaining why an ice cream flavor can't be Secretary of State. -- nm - TFox Sep 17, 07:33 2
        
        Depends on which flavor. -- nm - Will Hunting Sep 17, 07:34 1
        
        Chunky Monkey would be a great ambassador to the international community, and a bastion of foreign policy ideals. -- nm - Beryllium Sep 17, 07:45
      - You would need to set the bar either at the "top 400 vote getters", and it would curve steeply like presidential races... - TFox Sep 17, 07:30 2
        
        I'd think about 300 would be ideal, but it should be a fixed number regardless, pegged at a certain percentage of the decennial Census count -- nm - znufrii Sep 17, 07:33 1
        
        i know you are smart. i wish you would use that to generate smart ideas. -- nm - TFox Sep 17, 07:34

Post a message top

i know. and it's dumb. -- nm

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.