ST Alpha - "geebus, you're a sensitive bunch. by posting someone else's critique, i'm picking on ST?" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

In response to "that looks like fun. what can I pick-on that a bunch of (smart and generally good perspective-having) people here like but I've never seen? -- nm" by b.

geebus, you're a sensitive bunch. by posting someone else's critique, i'm picking on ST?

Posted by Guy (aka lostatlimbo) Nov 4 '09, 11:12

did you write the show?

i thought ST was a place for "discourse on a plethora of topics"?

Responses:

Bwahahahaha! -- nm - Dr.Vermin Nov 4, 11:23
Classic Guy� nm - Dignan Nov 4, 11:20
The energetic irony of this post could trigger cold fusion. -- nm - David Nov 4, 11:18
If you made a semi-coherant convincing argument based on something other than 2nd hand infor that is mostly trivial....... - musubi Nov 4, 11:17
"try re-reading the post" - b. Nov 4, 11:15 3
- i wasn't the one being critical!!! i re-posted his critics and then further explained how i interpreted them when others interpreted differently! - Guy Nov 4, 11:23 2
  - You misunderstand. She wasn't saying that you were criticizing ST. -- nm - mara Nov 4, 11:24 1
    - exactly. -- nm - b. Nov 4, 11:24
im also not even sure if Easterbrook likes the show or not. he clearly watches it. it is possible to be a fan of something and still be critical of it -- nm - Guy Nov 4, 11:14 11
- but you're not a fan. or a non-fan. you are a non-watcher. you know nothing of what you speak. -- nm - TFox Nov 4, 11:18 10
  - have you ever tried Rice Milk? if you thought it sounded odd initially and then someone told you that it was too watery, would that further support - Guy Nov 4, 11:21 9
    - Well....too watery for Rice Milk would be a lot more important to the taste of the food than "What goal to defend?" for a show about football's impact - Will Hunting Nov 4, 11:24
    - actually, I *have* tried rice milk. - znufrii Nov 4, 11:23 2
      - word. - TFox Nov 4, 11:25
      - Irrelevent!! -- nm - mara Nov 4, 11:24
    - see? fun! -- nm - b. Nov 4, 11:22
    - but i wouldn't go to war over it with people who've actually drank the shit either. -- nm - TFox Nov 4, 11:21 3
      - (and before you say "what war?", it's been two boards.) -- nm - TFox Nov 4, 11:22 2
        
        you've massively overestimated how much i care about this particular topic - Guy Nov 4, 11:25 1
        
        you need to learn how to not care about something better. - TFox Nov 4, 11:26
You're the one who's basing his critique as justification for you own pre-judgments on the show. - Will Hunting Nov 4, 11:14 1
- i wasn't on the cusp of watching it and he steered me away. - Guy Nov 4, 11:18

Post a message top

geebus, you're a sensitive bunch. by posting someone else's critique, i'm picking on ST?

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.