ST Alpha - "no, she's always been smart enough to sing great songs that other people write" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 159

In response to "None of which, I'm guessing, Madonna actually wrote. nm" by Dignan

no, she's always been smart enough to sing great songs that other people write

Posted by giganto (aka chris) Nov 18 '09, 19:11

if poker face is the best lady gaga can come up with out of her vast talent, she probably should do the same

Responses:

Well, we're also hearing the discoized arrangement of her songs - if you listen to their acoustic versions their superior pop songs - Reagen Nov 18, 19:26 12
- i'd still put madonna unplugged against gaga unplugged any day -- nm - giganto Nov 18, 19:28 8
  - Did you watch that "pre-gaga" performance that someone posted earlier today? nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:31 7
    - here -- (link) - Dignan Nov 18, 19:33 [Backboard] 6
      - that first part sounds like warmed over norah jones sh!t - giganto Nov 18, 19:42 5
        
        She sings there better than she plays the piano. -- nm - Max Nov 18, 19:55
        
        I think this is as close as you get to swallowing your pride, so I'll consider it a victory. nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:43 3
        
        it's American Idol level, at best -- nm - giganto Nov 18, 19:45 2
        
        Where Madonna wouldn't make it through the door. nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:50 1
        
        given the "winners" that AI has produced over it's history, i'm sure she would wear it as a badge of pride -- nm - giganto Nov 18, 20:00
- You could almost say that she's...selling out! nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:27
- they're. jeez. -- nm - Reagen Nov 18, 19:26 1
  - this is what happens when you listen too much. -- nm - Max Nov 18, 19:29
Gaga is an artist (note: I hate her art), Madonna's an entertainer. For me, that's already a (hairy) leg up. nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:14 1
- (Meaning, of course, that I was wrong. They're nothing alike.) nm - Dignan Nov 18, 19:18

Post a message top

no, she's always been smart enough to sing great songs that other people write

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.