ST Alpha - "dawson, you dont know them either. but you seem to be asserting that the daughter is more than likely selfish regardless." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 174

dawson, you dont know them either. but you seem to be asserting that the daughter is more than likely selfish regardless.

Posted by TFox Nov 19 '09, 09:35

to which i call shenanigans with extreme prejudice

Responses:

[deleted] 29
- MILs can stress a girl out. Giving birth is a stressful event. ... -- nm - Spawn Nov 19, 09:46
- (also note: the article is being written third hand. the nyt author is quoting a situation from another article entirely.) - TFox Nov 19, 09:39 7
  - well, if you're interested, here is the original post on grandparents.com - Roger More Nov 19, 09:48 5
    - I find it suspicious that she never mentions what color car her MIL drives. Likely cause she's selfish. (nm) - Jacky D si Nov 19, 09:53 2
      - [deleted] 1
        
        Contrarian? *giggle* Irony, thy name is JackDawson. (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 09:57
    - *laughing* that's so way worse. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:50 1
      - *nodding* -- nm - kelly Nov 19, 09:55
  - [deleted]
- She doesn't want anyone there, it seems. And whatever her reason might be; I can't find a good enough one to say she's wrong to do so. -- nm - Will Hunting Nov 19, 09:39 5
  - [deleted] 4
    - MILs don't get to make any demands in this situation. I can't think of any non-batshit crazy actions that would make the DIL selfish. -- nm - Reagen Nov 19, 09:49
    - You say it sounds suspicious......that's looking for the needle in a haystack level of searching to cast blame on the daughter in my mind. - Will Hunting Nov 19, 09:47 2
      - [deleted]
      - I did not want anyone waiting for me after my nuts were cut. - groiny Nov 19, 09:49
- bottom line, the person whose vagina is being obliterated has the call on who is / not there. nm -- nm - groiny Nov 19, 09:39 2
  - I just want you here, but please set up the camera this time. -- nm - mrs groiny si last night Nov 19, 09:41 1
    - groiny sex, volume 200, that's a wrap! nm -- nm - groiny Nov 19, 09:44
- her reason for not wanting the MIL is completely irrelevant. -- nm - loosilu Nov 19, 09:38 1
  - agreed. If she says no, the answer is no. -- nm - Beaker Nov 19, 09:39
- how can you not interpret MIL's reaction as implying the reason? that's insane. like, mexican insane. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:38 8
  - [deleted] 6
    - her vagina, her blood and crap on the floor, her choice. -- nm - loosilu Nov 19, 09:41
    - it is obvious that being able to argue whatever your client asks of you was a good career choice. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:41 4
      - Nice. (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 09:44
      - [deleted] 1
        
        i summarized it very accurately below, yes. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:44
      - [deleted]
  - *ding* (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 09:39
also, there is no context in which what the MIL did could be ok. -- nm - loosilu Nov 19, 09:36 9
- Agreed. She could be nurse working *in that* hospital, and the mom would still be well witihin her rights to ask her not to be there. (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 09:37 7
  - [deleted] 6
    - so, to summarize: the MIL is crazy, there are a plethora of reasons why the mother-to-be might do what she did... - TFox Nov 19, 09:44 5
      - [deleted] 3
        
        i tell you what. you give me a percentage on the daughter being a selfish bitch, and i'll just run with that. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:47 2
        
        [deleted]
        
        31.25% -- nm - Shaun Nov 19, 09:48
      - Don't forget: because a third hand account didn't list a specific reason. (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 09:45
- if i had been waffling on the issue, my mind would have been made up over dinner. -- nm - TFox Nov 19, 09:37

Post a message top

dawson, you dont know them either. but you seem to be asserting that the daughter is more than likely selfish regardless.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.