ST Alpha - "I'm shocked that people went off Big 3 with all their votes." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 157

In response to "David : I agree with you, but I am shocked he got any votes....." by groiny

I'm shocked that people went off Big 3 with all their votes.

Posted by Will Hunting (aka kelly) Nov 19 '09, 15:13

I don't see a real argument to be made that Carp/Linc/Wain aren't the top 3 in every voters eyes.

No matter how decent Vasquez's year was (and it was very good); he doesn't measure up to those 3.

Responses:

We're talking about 4 third place votes ouf 28, so few did. -- nm - David Nov 19, 15:16 4
- That still means 1 in 7 voters would think he's better than Carp/Linc/Wain - Will Hunting Nov 19, 15:21 3
  - I think there's a good arguement that Vazquez was every bit as good as Wainwright. (nm) - musubi Nov 19, 15:25 1
    - They're about even, but Wainwright was a bit better. I'm glad Vazzie got some love, though. -- nm - David Nov 19, 15:30
  - My guess is that it's folks who want to recognize others, anticipating a Carpenter/Lincecum battle for first. Wainwright wasn't supposed to be a facto -- nm - David Nov 19, 15:24

Post a message top

I'm shocked that people went off Big 3 with all their votes.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.