ST Alpha - "I think I would've put federer at #1. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 167

I think I would've put federer at #1. -- nm

Posted by mafic Dec 16 '09, 08:00

(No message)

Responses:

Brady got 6 votes, but Manning received none? -- nm - Let it Spawn, let it Spawn, let it Spawn! Dec 16, 08:19 10
- 3 Rings to 1 -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:20 2
  - [deleted] 1
    - As do I. This may take some heat but does anyone here actually believe that Tom Brady is a better QB than Peyton? -- nm - Christmas VacaShaun Dec 16, 08:24
- rings count -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:20 3
  - Records and MVPs don't? -- nm - Let it Spawn, let it Spawn, let it Spawn! Dec 16, 08:21 2
    - sure, but not as much as rings -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:22 1
      - Hmm. The entire team wears the rings, but I guess I can see their point. -- nm - Let it Spawn, let it Spawn, let it Spawn! Dec 16, 08:25
- [deleted] 2
  - *sad face* (nm) - Dan Marino Dec 16, 08:21 1
    - He's only the best *passer* in NFL history. -- nm - Christmas VacaShaun Dec 16, 08:22
[deleted] 14
- Word. He has dominated for 9 of the 10 years of this decade. Phelps and Bolt dominated one set of Olympic Games. -- nm - Jim Dec 16, 08:07 13
  - Pujols has been the best player in baseball for the a lot of the decade, but he hasn't dominated a sport the way either Phelps, Federer or Woods. - musubi Dec 16, 08:17 1
    - [deleted]
  - Phelps has dominated his sport. World Swimmer of the Year 6 times. 4 Golds at the 2003 Worlds, 5 in 2005, 7 in 2007, 5 in 2009 -- nm - Roger More Dec 16, 08:12
  - I'd rank em 1) Tiger 2) Federer 3) Pujols 4) Tim Duncan 5) Lance 6) Phelps -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:11 7
    - I see the top 3 as Tiger, Federer, and Phelps, but I'm unclear on the order. - the wrong element, bad guy Dec 16, 08:19 2
      - I think I agree with this. (nm) - musubi Dec 16, 08:20 1
        
        ditto -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:21
    - question: why weren't lebron and kobe on the list? didn't dominate consistently enough? -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:12 3
      - People didn't vote for them. They didn't list out anyone who got 1 vote (5 guys) - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:15
      - Lebron won how many titles? -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:14
      - They canceled each other out. -- nm - Let it Spawn, let it Spawn, let it Spawn! Dec 16, 08:13
  - Phelps dominated 2 actually....6 golds in 2004 with 2 bronze. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:08 1
    - Ooops...doesn't change my stance though. -- nm - Jim Dec 16, 08:09
No Michael Vick? -- nm - Cats Dec 16, 08:03
I can't cuz for 2 reasons A) He didn't become tennis god till 2003. Tiger was all 10 years. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:03 35
- But God quit this year. -- nm - Let it Spawn, let it Spawn, let it Spawn! Dec 16, 08:11 1
  - For 2010...new decade. And he'll be back by March is my guess. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:15
- for me that's a triviality of timing. in those 7 years he's won more grand slam titles than any other man has in a career. - mafic Dec 16, 08:08 1
  - The 2nd part is more vital then. He plays 7 matches vs 1 guy at a time. He could be awful but still better than the guy he's playing and advance. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:09
- but there's no physical exertion in golf. "oh dear, the sun is beating down on me pretty hard today. caddie, give me my visor." puh-lease -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:05 30
  - I take it you haven't played the game then. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:07 1
    - I'm sore as balls after the first round of the year. Golf uses muscles that you don't use on a day-to-day basis. -- nm - Christmas VacaShaun Dec 16, 08:19
  - Half of most sports is hand-eye coordination. Golf takes it to an extreme. -- nm - Beryllium (iPhone) Dec 16, 08:07 10
    - When someone is out there guarding the hole on the golf course... - Jim Dec 16, 08:08 9
      - by that reasoning, should we put a linebacker in the middle of a 100m dash, then? -- nm - merry xmas and happy znu year Dec 16, 08:11 1
        
        I'd be more impressed. -- nm - Jim Dec 16, 08:12
      - thank you! -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:09 6
        
        And that's not to take away from Tiger or any other world class golfer. I'm just saying, I'll take Pujols, Manning, Sid the Kid, Lebron over the - Jim Dec 16, 08:12 5
        
        BTW: did you see Matthew Berry's take on Houston's D I posted last night? -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:13 2
        
        I did now...Thanks. -- nm - Jim Dec 16, 08:15 1
        
        he had teh stats to back up my thoughts :) -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:19
        
        Sid isn't even the best player on his team... -- nm - Beaker Dec 16, 08:12 1
        
        Psst...not a big hockey guy. Sub Crosby for whoever is the best. -- nm - Jim Dec 16, 08:13
  - you try swinging a golf club with any type of precision or consistency. -- nm - merry xmas and happy znu year Dec 16, 08:06 16
    - yes it's a skill and it's very mental...but i can't compare it to swimming or tennis or basketball, etc. -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:08 15
      - it's more than just mental. it's about physical control. - merry xmas and happy znu year Dec 16, 08:09 14
        
        i suppose...but i feel like athletes from other sports could play golf...but that's not necessarily true when you reverse it. doesn't that say someth - Fednog Dec 16, 08:11 13
        
        To play golf at a world class level? No way. (nm) - musubi Dec 16, 08:15 6
        
        Just look at those club-pros who qualify for the PGA Championship...these guys shoot 65 at home...shoot 80 at this tourney. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:17 5
        
        question: could that be because they have more opportunities to practice on their home (what is called?) turfs? -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:19 4
        
        Partly. But it goes to show that the elite get ridiculous scores on whatever course they play. (nm) - musubi Dec 16, 08:24
        
        More that the big boys play on courses mortals aren't familiar with. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:24 1
        
        Plus most tour players get 1 shot a year at any given course so shooting 68 anywhere is insanely great. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:25
        
        sure, it would make sense that they know every in and out, nook and cranny of their home course. - merry xmas and happy znu year Dec 16, 08:21
        
        Sure, just not very well. Have you ever seen Michael Jordan play golf? -- nm - mara Dec 16, 08:14 1
        
        or Charles Barkley? -- nm - Reagen Dec 16, 08:17
        
        No...that speaks to specialization. Michael Jordan, best ever at his game couldn't perform as well as a modest Double-A baseball player. - Will Hunting Dec 16, 08:13 1
        
        but there was a tennis pro (lleyton hewitt's coach) i think his name was andrew draper...he was a pro on the ATP and now he's a pro on the PGA...i don - Fednog Dec 16, 08:17
        
        could they play golf? sure. could they do it at a professional level? doubtful. -- nm - merry xmas and happy znu year Dec 16, 08:12 1
        
        good point. never looked at it like that. i kind of put physical exertion (like feats of human anatomy) very high up when ranking sports, but your r - Fednog Dec 16, 08:15
Where did Armstrong rank? -- nm - Beryllium (iPhone) Dec 16, 08:02 3
- I think Phelps should be ahead of him. - the wrong element, bad guy Dec 16, 08:13
- 2nd. i would have put federer #1 too. when is the women's one coming out? -- nm - Fednog Dec 16, 08:03
- #2 -- nm - Roger More Dec 16, 08:03

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.