ST Alpha - "We can both agree on this. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 158

In response to "No, Peyton doesn't, I'd bet. -- nm" by Will Hunting

We can both agree on this. -- nm

Posted by Redmond (aka redmond) Dec 27 '09, 16:07

(No message)

Responses:

No, you said the coach agrees...I said I'm sure Peyton doesn't. Since Peyton's very likely the coach of Indy..we disagree - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:09 20
- As we saw last week. The Star Quarterback isn't always right. -- nm - Redmond Dec 27, 16:10 19
  - Peyton Manning as a game technician is about 100x better then Brett Favre can dream of being. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:11 17
    - I've said it for several years now and I mean it every time. Manning is the best I've ever seen. -- nm - David Dec 27, 16:12 11
      - Between him and Brady, I really don't know where to make a bad choice there. - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:15 1
        
        Dwight Clark and Freddie Solomon weren't exactly the best receivers in the game either... - Stephen Dec 27, 16:38
      - I had the luxury of seeing Montana (live a bunch of times) and he is the best I have ever seen. - Redmond Dec 27, 16:14 8
        
        Montana is a much more limited QB than Manning. -- nm - David Dec 27, 16:15 7
        
        It's hard to compare salary cap era vs. non cap era. However Montana was cooler under pressure in my opinion. - Redmond Dec 27, 16:17 6
        
        I'm not talking about teams. I'm talking about players. Montana was an overachiever with a noodle arm. Manning is an overachiever with a hand cannon. -- nm - David Dec 27, 16:22 3
        
        You didn't mean that second overachiever, I think. -- nm - TFox Dec 27, 16:23 2
        
        I did. Manning practices like an undrafted free agent. -- nm - David Dec 27, 16:25 1
        
        oh i see. i was thinking overachiever like "someone who achieves more than they would seem capable of". -- nm - TFox Dec 27, 16:26
        
        No...his last team went 9 & 7 and lost in the wild-card round. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:19 1
        
        Damn, you're right. I will admit that I was wrong once today :) -- nm - Redmond Dec 27, 16:27
    - Yet they both have 1 ring. -- nm - Redmond Dec 27, 16:12 4
      - Which proves what? That Peyton played against better teams quite frequently? - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:14 3
        
        It proves they both have a ring. You compared and so did I. - Redmond Dec 27, 16:16 2
        
        No..I compared actual QB skills...you compared team accomplishments. They are different animals. -- nm - Will Hunting Dec 27, 16:17
        
        You get defeated by yourself inside a thread often, huh? -- nm - TFox Dec 27, 16:16
  - (see Favre vs the Coach) at least Manning will listen and sit his ass down -- nm - Redmond Dec 27, 16:10

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.