ST Alpha - "Sherlock Holmes seems to be fairly polarizing. nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

Sherlock Holmes seems to be fairly polarizing. nm

Posted by Dignan (aka Dignan) Jan 5 '10, 13:15

I'm genuinely shocked that so many people love it.

Responses:

Enjoyed it, but didn't love it. -- nm - znufrii Jan 5, 13:30
I saw it with my brother - he loved it, I did not. -- nm - Max Jan 5, 13:16 6
- I did not care for it - SM loved it -- nm - Pippy Bells Jan 5, 13:30
- Min? -- nm - con_carne Jan 5, 13:27
- [deleted]
- I liked it, my brother didn't. -- nm - nubby Jan 5, 13:19
- There were 5 of us. No one loved it. -- nm - Diva Jan 5, 13:17 1
  - If I hadn't been sandwiched right in the middle of the row, I might have walked out. nm - Dignan Jan 5, 13:18
i liked it way way more than i expected based on what i read here. -- nm - Andie Jan 5, 13:16 12
- I think more people here liked it than hated. nm - Dignan Jan 5, 13:17 3
  - "Hated" is a strong word. It should be reserved for horrible things like "the flu" or "Dignan." - JaxSean Jan 5, 13:20 2
    - My Shanghai Knights vibe wasn't very far off the mark. nm - Dignan Jan 5, 13:21 1
      - Except smarter. Kinda. -- nm - JaxSean Jan 5, 13:27
- spoilers - Andie Jan 5, 13:16 7
  - Especially after seeing Avatar. -- nm - JaxSean Jan 5, 13:17 2
    - i'm still in the "Avatar is a B" camp. -- nm - Andie Jan 5, 13:20 1
      - I mean the CGI. - JaxSean Jan 5, 13:25
  - which parts? backgrounds? -- nm - Max Jan 5, 13:17 3
    - yes - Andie Jan 5, 13:19 2
      - I agree with this -- nm - Pippy Bells Jan 5, 13:31
      - it looked like a diorama. -- nm - Diva Jan 5, 13:20

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.