ST Alpha - "Phantom Menace Review: (B+) nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 155

Phantom Menace Review: (B+) nm

Posted by Dignan (aka Dignan) Jan 12 '10, 12:35

nm

Responses:

Alright, a friend of mine forwarded that to me weeks ago. I refused to spend 60+ minutes watching it all. Can I get a recap? -- nm - oblique Jan 12, 12:39 5
- I didn't think I would either, but you get going and you don't want to stop. - Reagen Jan 12, 12:41 3
  - And it's really quite a good primer (ha!) about screenplay story structure. -- nm - Dano Jan 12, 12:51 1
    - yup. Dude knows his stuff. -- nm - Reagen Jan 12, 12:52
  - That's what she said. -- nm - loosilu Jan 12, 12:43
- it is funny. -- nm - Beaker Jan 12, 12:40
I'd say A. Who did the voice over? Regardless, some of the plotholes he pointed out were even worse than I remembered. -- nm - Inigo Jan 12, 12:39 5
- It reminded me of Vern in tone. - Dignan Jan 12, 12:49
- I believe he is suppossed to be Buffalo Bill from Silence of The Lambs. -- nm - Beaker Jan 12, 12:40 3
  - Doesn't sound like Ted Levine to me. More like Kevin from The Office, but I know it's not him. -- nm - Inigo Jan 12, 12:45 2
    - it's not him, but he's trying to imitate him. -- nm - Reagen Jan 12, 12:49 1
      - right -- nm - Beaker Jan 12, 12:50
What exactly is this that everyone seems to be talking about since yesterday? -- nm - Cuzzin Todd Jan 12, 12:39 1
- Here - Dignan Jan 12, 12:47 [youtube] 1
(and the behind the scenes stuff at the end is *damning*) -- nm - Reagen Jan 12, 12:37 9
- Is Anakin caught injecting midichlorians? -- nm - Max Jan 12, 12:39 1
  - it's almost the equivalent. -- nm - Reagen Jan 12, 12:40
- I was honestly a bit relieved to know that *they* knew it sucked. nm - Dignan Jan 12, 12:38 6
  - I think it was more that they were scared to say anything against George's ideas. - Inigo Jan 12, 12:43 5
    - Sure, but Lucas himself knew he blew it. He looked *devastated* after that screening. nm - Dignan Jan 12, 12:46 3
      - If he knew he blew it, why did he keep control for the sequels? -- nm - Roger More Jan 12, 12:49 2
        
        Cameron-sized ego, without the payoff and talent. -- nm - Beryllium Jan 12, 12:50
        
        "I know what I did wrong -- I can fix it." nm - Dignan Jan 12, 12:50
    - no one wants to risk getting booted from the first Star Wars prequel. -- nm - loosilu Jan 12, 12:44
it's rather cathartic. -- nm - Reagen Jan 12, 12:36

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.