ST Alpha - "I am confused: how can a review unmake a movie? You either thought it sucked or you didn't. A review *shouldn't* be able to make something suck. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

I am confused: how can a review unmake a movie? You either thought it sucked or you didn't. A review shouldn't be able to make something suck. -- nm

Posted by TFox Jan 12 '10, 13:45

(No message)

Responses:

It's an analysis, not a review. -- nm - mara Jan 12, 13:55 3
- i just watched the first part and i feel way better. when i saw PH in the theatre i was totally lost. now i know why. -- nm - Andie Jan 12, 14:06 1
  - That's exactly how I felt. -- nm - mara Jan 12, 14:11
- Totally. He peels away layers and opens my eyes. I'm angry at myself for not seeing all this for myself. I feel (more) like a retard. -- nm - Mop (229 lbs) Jan 12, 14:03
Just watch it. You can still like the movie, and think the guy has a great argument. -- nm - Inigo Jan 12, 13:48 1
- [deleted]
[deleted] 5
- the comparison in characterization between the trilogies was the first kill shot. - Mel Profit Jan 12, 13:52 4
  - Like you said before the descriptions of the prequels characters by his friends crush the script. - Inigo Jan 12, 13:56 3
    - that really was eye opening... - Mel Profit Jan 12, 13:57 2
      - Were you trying to come up with characteristics too? -- nm - Inigo Jan 12, 14:10 1
        
        admittedly yes... - Mel Profit Jan 12, 14:13
You might have a jumble of thoughts about why you don't like a film (or a book or whatever) but you probably haven't gone through them systematically -- nm - Roger More Jan 12, 13:47

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.